Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
Teacher quality is seen as an important lever for influencing students’ short-run achievement on standardized tests, non-test outcomes, and longer-term outcomes, including college-going behavior and earnings in the labor market. There is also evidence of “teacher quality gaps,” i.e., teachers are unevenly distributed across schools, and schools serving higher percentages of historically disadvantaged students tend to have less access to more qualified and effective teachers.
Differences between schools in the qualifications of newly hired teachers appear to be a contributor to these gaps. However, there is only limited research on the extent to which this is related to differences in applications to schools, with schools serving more disadvantaged student populations tending to have thinner application pools. In this paper, we seek to add to the understanding of applicants’ preferences for working in different types of schools by analyzing how school characteristics relate to the supply of teacher applicants and do this with harmonized data both within and across districts and charter organizations.
We explore teacher applicants’ school preferences using rich data from an applicant tracking system (ATS) operated by Nimble Hiring, PBC. (henceforth “Nimble”). Nimble provides services to a wide range of school districts and charter organizations that use the platform to post job openings, receive and screen applications, and track applicants’ advancement in the hiring process.
In this study, we use two features of the Nimble platform to analyze applicant preferences. One allows candidates to apply to job postings associated with a single location, and the other allows candidates to choose a subset of schools they are interested in from among all the schools associated with a pooled job posting. The latter is important as it is usually difficult to disentangle the characteristics of the school from the job.
We use these two types of data to address the following research questions:
What do teacher application patterns reveal about their preferences for school characteristics?
What do applicants’ selections from a menu of schools associated with a job posting reveal about teacher preferences for school characteristics?
Is there heterogeneity in preferences across applicant characteristics?
This study’s contribution to the literature on how applicant preferences shape teacher labor markets is the introduction of additional nuance. We broaden the range of districts studied, and our findings on within-district application patterns contrast with those from prior studies; we find that disparities in application volumes for high-need schools arise primarily from differences across districts rather than systematic avoidance of particular schools within districts. While our findings regarding applicants' choices from menus of schools are broadly consistent with the existing literature about teachers’ preferences for working with fewer disadvantaged students, we nevertheless find a willingness among applicants to work in a wide range of schools in a given district.