Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How Does Professional Learning Influence Culturally Responsive Teaching? Evidence on Teacher Efficacy and Beliefs

Saturday, November 7, 8:30 to 10:00am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Harvard

Abstract

Policymakers increasingly invest in professional learning (PL) to improve instruction, yet there is limited evidence on which mechanisms translate these investments into changes in classroom practice. This study examines how PL focused on culturally responsive (CR) instruction is associated with teachers’ instructional practices and whether teacher beliefs and efficacy help explain this relationship.While prior research shows that PL can improve teaching and student outcomes, less is known about how PL targeting culturally responsive instruction influences day-to-day classroom practice and the mechanisms through which such changes occur. In particular, teachers’ beliefs and self-efficacy are often theorized as important drivers of instructional change, yet few studies have examined these pathways simultaneously within a single analytic framework.Using survey data from 186 middle school mathematics teachers across four U.S. districts serving diverse student populations, we employ structural equation modeling (SEM) to estimate both direct and indirect associations between PL and teachers’ reported use of culturally responsive instructional practices. The analytic model includes latent measures of PL focused on CR instruction, teacher beliefs, teacher efficacy, and classroom implementation of CR practices.Results indicate that participation in PL focused on CR instruction is positively associated with greater use of culturally responsive practices in the classroom. Findings further suggest that teacher efficacy plays a meaningful role in this relationship: participation in PL is positively associated with higher levels of efficacy, and efficacy is, in turn, positively associated with classroom implementation. In contrast, teachers’ beliefs about culturally responsive instruction show a weaker and less consistent association with instructional practice once teacher efficacy and professional learning are taken into account.These findings have implications for the design of professional learning policies and programs. While efforts to influence teachers’ beliefs may be important, our results suggest that policies focusing solely on belief change may be insufficient to shift classroom practice. Instead, professional learning initiatives may be more effective when they explicitly support teachers in developing the skills, strategies, and confidence needed to implement culturally responsive practices, including opportunities for practice-based learning such as modeling, guided rehearsal, and feedback. Strengthening teacher efficacy may therefore represent a more reliable pathway for translating investments in professional learning into meaningful changes in classroom instruction.

Author