Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
Budgeting reforms are critical instruments for resource mobilization and the delivery of public services, yet the specific mechanisms through which these reforms diffuse—and how those mechanisms vary based on the reform’s underlying values—remain underexamined. This study addresses this gap by comparing the diffusion of two distinct types of reforms: Performance Budgeting (PB), a technocratic, non-equity-driven reform focused on managerial efficiency, and Social Equity Budgeting (SEB), an equity-oriented reform designed to address historical disparities and restorative justice.The research employs a qualitative comparative case study design focusing on four diverse US municipalities: Chicago (IL), Kansas City (MO), Tacoma (WA), and San Diego (CA). The data were derived from 19 semi-structured in-depth interviews with budget directors, equity officers, and city stakeholders, supplemented by a comprehensive content analysis of official documents, including budget memos, council minutes, and equity action plans spanning from 2012 to 2024. By selecting jurisdictions that have adopted both PB and SEB, the study provides a unique opportunity to observe how different policy contents activate distinct diffusion pathways within the same institutional environments.The findings reveal that the diffusion of Performance Budgeting is primarily driven by technocratic learning and professional network mechanisms. PB is framed as a "value-neutral" modernization tool aimed at efficiency and accountability. For instance, San Diego’s adoption was characterized by a formal learning process involving the study of ten peer jurisdictions to identify best practices. These reforms are largely legitimized by standardized professional benchmarks from organizations like the Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA).In contrast, Social Equity Budgeting diffuses through recognition-, ideology-, and network-driven pathways. Rather than seeking technical efficiency, SEB adoption is often a response to social upheaval—such as the 2020 racial justice protests—and a normative recognition of historical disinvestment and systemic bias. Examples from Tacoma’s "Equity Index" and Chicago’s "Equity Budgeting Working Group" demonstrate that SEB requires "local translation" and a focus on "intentionality." While PB relies on standardized replication, SEB spreads through ideological hubs like the Government Alliance on Race and Equity (GARE), which provide the moral and political vocabulary necessary for local legitimacy.This study contributes to the literature by demonstrating that policy content and values fundamentally shape diffusion mechanisms. It bridges the gap between public budgeting and policy diffusion scholarship, offering a more nuanced framework for understanding how transformative administrative reforms travel across local governments.