Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
Why do citizens fail to contribute to collective goods even when doing so is legally required, nearly costless, and takes only minutes? Census response presents exactly this puzzle. Despite decades of investment in reducing structural barriers — simplified questionnaires, multiple response modes, prepaid postage, and widespread outreach — self-response rates have held at roughly 67 percent across the 2010 and 2020 censuses. The persistence of noncompliance after structural costs are removed suggests that the binding constraints on the remaining nonrespondents are behavioral rather than logistical.This study tests that proposition using a preregistered survey experiment with 1,500 prior nonrespondents to the 2020 Census. Respondents were randomly assigned to one of five behaviorally framed messages or a control condition. The treatments varied whether the message made program benefits salient, framed nonresponse as a collective funding loss to the community, combined loss framing with a trust repair appeal, made political representation consequences salient, or communicated the legal obligation to respond and the potential financial penalty for refusal. Contribution intentions for the 2030 Census served as the primary outcome.Three findings stand out. Informational messages emphasizing program benefits or political representation did not significantly increase stated willingness to contribute, casting doubt on the assumption that noncompliance primarily reflects information deficits. Loss-framed messages that made the community consequences of nonresponse concrete and personally relevant produced significant increases in contribution intentions, consistent with prospect theory. Legal obligation messages also increased willingness to contribute, indicating that institutional compliance signals operate through a distinct and effective channel. Trust-affirming messages did not improve intentions and appeared to attenuate the effect of loss framing, a pattern consistent with psychological reactance rather than belief updating.These findings carry direct implications for public agencies designing outreach strategies. Administrative messaging that frames nonresponse as an active choice to impose costs on the community, or that communicates the institutional authority behind mandatory contribution requirements, outperforms traditional informational outreach among prior nonrespondents. Because census undercounts fall disproportionately on marginalized communities, shifting outreach toward behaviorally informed messaging can also reduce inequities in political representation and federal resource allocation that follow from systematic undercounting.