Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Personal Damage from Tropical Disasters Increases Support for Climate Change Policies among Individualists and Hierarchists

Thursday, November 5, 3:30 to 5:00pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Boston University

Abstract

Securing broad public support for climate policy is one of the most pressing challenges in efforts to mitigate climate change, particularly in the United States, where partisan polarization has long impeded legislative action. While previous research has established that Republicans who personally experienced damage from tropical disasters tend to express greater concern about climate change and show stronger support for related policies, the psychological mechanisms driving this shift have remained underexplored. This study investigates those mechanisms through the lens of cultural theory, focusing on two value orientations (individualism and hierarchism) that scholars have consistently linked to lower risk perception of environmental hazards and heightened resistance to climate regulation.Cultural theory proposes that individuals' worldviews shape how they perceive and respond to risk. Individualists, who prioritize personal autonomy and free markets, tend to resist regulatory solutions that constrain economic freedom. Hierarchists, who defer to established social institutions and authority structures, are similarly inclined to downplay environmental risks that might challenge existing orders of power and production. Both orientations, therefore, represent significant psychological barriers to climate concern and policy support, making them important targets for understanding when and why those barriers can be overcome.We examine whether personal experience of damage from tropical disasters moderates the relationship between these cultural orientations and climate attitudes, and whether any such moderation varies by partisan identity. Drawing on an original, representative survey of 3,945 registered voters in Florida, a state uniquely exposed to hurricane risk and politically emblematic of national partisan divisions, paired with administrative voter file data, we find robust support for both the individualism and hierarchism hypotheses. Among Floridians who sustained personal damage from tropical storms or hurricanes, higher levels of both individualism and hierarchism are associated with greater climate concern and stronger support for climate policy. Crucially, these effects are not conditional on partisanship or ideological self-identification, suggesting that direct disaster experience can reshape climate attitudes through psychological pathways that transcend conventional political divides.These findings carry meaningful implications for climate communication and public policy design. They suggest that personal losses from tropical disasters can disrupt deeply held cultural priors, even among populations traditionally resistant to environmental regulation. Policymakers and advocates seeking to build cross-partisan coalitions around climate action may therefore benefit from centering the concrete, local consequences of climate-driven disasters rather than relying solely on abstract scientific projections. Framing climate policy in terms of community resilience, property protection, and institutional preservation may resonate specifically with individualist and hierarchist constituencies. This study thus contributes both psychological nuance and practical direction to ongoing efforts to broaden the political constituency for meaningful climate action.

Author