Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Can Enhanced Street Lighting Generate Citywide Crime Reductions?

Friday, November 6, 3:30 to 5:00pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 1st Floor/Lobby Level, Room: Columbus

Abstract

Street crime is thought to be influenced by ambient lighting conditions, yet most causal evidence comes from small-scale interventions in limited areas or short-term evaluations. Whether enhanced lighting can improve public safety at a larger, jurisdiction-wide scale over a sustained period remains an open question. One vehicle for testing this is the large-scale replacement of legacy streetlighting with light-emitting diode (LED) technology. LED streetlights offer substantially greater luminosity, more uniform coverage, and lower operating costs than the sodium-vapor and metal-halide fixtures they replace. Many major American cities have undertaken or completed citywide LED conversion programs. Philadelphia is among the most recent to do so at a comprehensive, municipally coordinated scale. Between August 2023 and February 2026, the Philadelphia Energy Authority (PEA) replaced 124,985 fixtures across 35,781 street segments. This study estimates the effect of Philadelphia’s citywide LED streetlight upgrade on several measures of crime, including total outdoor and indoor crime, violent crime, property crime, nuisance crime, and gun violence. The phased and geographically uneven rollout generates plausibly exogenous variation in the timing of LED installation across street segments, enabling a difference-in-differences identification strategy. Using data spanning July 2022 through June 2026, we report estimates of the LED installation on each outcome.

Given the difficultly of undertaking a citywide streetlighting conversion, the panelists will also discuss other types of lighting interventions that cities have implemented in the past or might implement, and what past or ongoing research efforts exist to understand the range of potential lighting interventions in cities. This study is also part of a much larger body of crime prevention through environmental design (CPTED) literature. This study, and some others, reveals a surprising level of crime reduction tied to a change in environmental conditions--along with minimal evidence of displacement. These findings provide new insights to mayors who are considering CPTED interventions as tools for addressing crime and violence on particular streets or in particular neighborhoods.

Author