Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
This study examines how school system leaders respond organizationally to a rapidly shifting educational marketplace amid the expansion of universal Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) in early adopter states, Arizona and Florida. ESA policies broaden the educational marketplace by allowing families to use public dollars for options that have historically been privately funded, including private schools, homeschooling, microschools, and services. We draw on resource dependence theory (RDT) and the concept of competition as socially constructed to assess how educational organizations perceive and respond to competition for critical resources—most notably students, funding, and public legitimacy.
RDT posits that organizations are constrained by their reliance on external environments for survival, as key resources are controlled by actors outside the organization (Hillman, Withers, & Collins, 2009). In education markets, where funding is tied to student enrollment, universal ESAs intensify this dependence by increasing volatility in student flows, redistributing decision-making power to families, and introducing new forms of competition from nontraditional providers. These dynamics build on already competitive landscapes and differentially affect organizations depending on their vulnerability to financial pressures and capacity to compete. Prior studies of charter schools and small-scale voucher programs suggest that while some organizations do not respond to increased market pressures (Bulkley & Fisler, 2003; Wells, 1998), others demonstrate varied responses including programmatic innovation or improvement (Hess, 2001; Rofes, 1998), marketing, and recruitment (Jabbar, 2015; 2016; Jabbar & Creed, 2020; Lubienski, 2005).
To understand varied organizational responses to universal ESAs, we employ a two-state, two-district embedded case study design, drawing on 40+ interviews with state, national, and local leaders from all sectors (traditional public, charter, private, microschools, and homeschooling). We examine whether leaders pursue substantive innovation—developing new models and programmatic approaches to attract, retain, and serve students—or symbolic adaptation, adopting visible but superficial changes to maintain legitimacy in a competitive field. Based on RDT and prior research, we expect organizations facing greater resource vulnerability to be more likely to pursue substantive changes.
Preliminary findings indicate that competition was already prevalent in Arizona and Florida prior to ESA expansion, suggesting many organizations were prepared to respond. For organizations that perceived threat and scarcity from ESAs, common responses include substantive programmatic changes to improve or differentiate offerings (e.g., improved curriculum or expanded dual immersion), alongside investments in marketing. Some leaders, particularly in the traditional public sector, reported a new form of diversification: “unbundling” of services for a fee (e.g., allowing non-enrolled students to participate in courses or sports). In contrast, some leaders who view ESAs as an opportunity reported developing new structural models of schooling, particularly microschools and homeschool-hybrid models. These responses vary across states, with Arizona’s less restrictive regulatory environment enabling greater expansion of alternative models compared to in Florida.
These findings highlight how policy-driven market expansion interacts with existing competitive environments to shape organizational behavior. By comparing responses across two state contexts, the findings demonstrate how differences in policy design and regulation influence the range and nature of organizational responses, offering insight for policymakers designing choice systems.