Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Stranded in Ohio: Grid Governance, Wholesale Markets and the Political Economy of Power Plant Revaluations

Saturday, November 7, 3:30 to 5:00pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 5th Floor, Room: Vermont

Abstract

This study is an investigation into a recent episode of asset stranding in the United States power plant sector. What influenced the decisions of owners and buyers of nuclear and coal power plants between 2008 and 2022 after natural gas prices plummeted? Using five illustrative cases from the state of Ohio, the paper aims first to understand why incumbent investor-owned utilities, having long secured subsidies despite the introduction of market-based pricing, faced increased uncertainty over their future chances – a change prompting the selling and decommissioning of many of their power plants. Then it explores the curious ubiquity of private equity and other financial-firm buyers: Why would these investors – with business models reliant on creditors who care about cashflow – want to purchase power plants that produce costly electricity and that utilities had deemed stranded assets? The paper’s argument builds on work by American, Comparative and International Political Economy scholars. However, in contrast to the typical emphasis on state and federal policy arenas, its argument draws attention to the role of RTOs and wholesale electric markets, incorporating insights from economic sociologists, EU specialists, grid governance experts and legal scholars, all of whom view markets and their governance as extensions of politics. Empirically, the study makes use of original data, enabling a deep dive into asset revaluation processes of power plants and revealing the political impact of the massive U.S. market-building project. An additional aim of the paper is to contribute to discussions about research transparency and qualitative methods. In an effort to meet new data access expectations, I will publicly store the data (at the Qualitative Data Repository) using two experimental formats: Financial biographies of power plants and multilinear timelines. In this way, I hope to advance knowledge accumulation by improving qualitative data packaging. Lastly, the paper investigates past asset stranding with an eye to generating policy to help manage future bouts, such as the ones predicted by critics of the current United States buildup of fossil fuel infrastructure.

Author