Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
Introduction/Background: California’s accountability system is the primary method through which the state identifies districts in need of academic improvement. Districts whose student performance is found wanting in more than one category are identified for “Differentiated Assistance” – a label that triggers a support cycle that is intended to influence resource and programmatic decisions with the ultimate goal of enhancing student academic success.
Purpose/Research Question: This study examines the effects of Differentiated Assistance (DA)—California’s triggered support mechanism for local education agencies (LEAs) that fall short on key student outcome benchmarks—on both resource use and student achievement in the post-pandemic period. Prior research suggests that DA identification can improve subsequent student achievement, but existing evidence is limited to pre‑pandemic years and offers little insight into how DA may shift LEA resource configurations and intervention strategies.
Data: We use state administrative data and financial planning documents from the 2021-2022 school year to the 2024-2025 school year. The administrative data includes DA eligibility criteria by student subgroup and outcome – suspension rate, graduation rate, chronic absenteeism rate, math and ELA tests for grades 3-8 & 11, and performance on English language development tests. In general, this outcome data is available for each of 13 student groups, including race, socioeconomic status, and students with disabilities. For the financial planning and resource allocation, the relevant outcome is the district’s stated planning response: which student groups, indicators, action types, and planned expenditures it chooses to name in their accountability documents after DA identification.
Research Design and Methods: We use a regression discontinuity design (RDD) to estimate the causal effect of DA eligibility on districts’ subsequent financial planning, resource allocation, and student outcomes. We use a variation of the “binding score” method that allows each district to have a distinct eligibility variable and cutoff, depending on which performance indicators for which student groups are close to the DA-triggering performance level. We identify the binding score for each LEA in the 2022 assignment year and match the DA assignments to resource allocation and student achievement in the 22-23, 23-24, and 24-25 school years, allowing us to track the impact of DA as it unfolds across school years.
Results/Findings: We find that DA is overwhelmingly triggered by districts’ chronic absenteeism and suspension rates and that students with disabilities are the triggering group in 50% of districts identified for support. We also find that the planning documents do not show a concordant shift in resource allocation toward the triggering groups, particularly for students with disabilities. Consequently, we find no improvement in subsequent student performance, either for districts overall or for the identified groups, as a result of DA.
Conclusion/Implications: The structure of California’s school funding and accountability are misaligned in ways that make the lack of effect not wholly surprising. In their accountability planning documents. Districts are encouraged to define resource allocation according to student groups identified in the state’s funding formula, rather than the groups that trigger designation under the accountability system.