Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
How should organizations evaluate workers when formal credentials may reflect both real skill and easy-to-read signals? This paper studies that question in the context of U.S. Air Force officer promotions. Over time, the Air Force repeatedly changed whether promotion boards could see officers’ advanced academic degrees on their promotion records, including major policy changes in 2008, 2014, and 2022. These repeated policy reversals create a rare opportunity to study how credential visibility shapes promotion and retention within the same large public-sector workforce, and whether those effects are consistent across policy episodes or change over time.
The paper asks whether shifts in the visibility of degree information change who gets promoted and who stays in service. More specifically, it examines whether advanced degrees function primarily as indicators of productivity or as visible signals that promotion boards rely on when evaluating officers. This question matters for both personnel policy and broader debates about credentialism, merit-based advancement, and talent management in public institutions.
The analysis uses longitudinal administrative personnel data on active-duty Air Force officers, including monthly observations on education, career field, promotion outcomes, and retention from 2005 to 2025. I use changes in degree masking and unmasking to compare promotion patterns across periods when boards could and could not observe advanced degrees, to test whether credential visibility also affected retention patterns for officers with and without advanced degrees, and to examine whether these effects are concentrated in career fields where degrees appear to have been especially salient before the policy changes.
Preliminary evidence from earlier work suggests that the promotion premium associated with holding an advanced degree fell by roughly 50 percent after the 2014 masking policy. Earlier results also suggest that non-degree holders in some operational career fields became more likely to pro-mote once degree information was hidden. These patterns are consistent with promotion boards using degree visibility as a meaningful signal in selection decisions. The current project extends that earlier analysis by incorporating additional policy reversals, richer administrative data, and retention outcomes to better understand how credential visibility shapes promotion and retention across officers’ careers.
This paper contributes to research on information design, internal labor markets, and public-sector personnel policy. More broadly, it provides evidence on how evaluation rules shape incentives for educational investment, advancement, and retention in a high-stakes public organization, with important implications for military workforce stability and readiness.