Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Voluntary Minimum Wages in the Public Childcare Sector

Saturday, November 7, 10:15 to 11:45am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Boston University

Abstract

Both the Army and the American private sector face a childcare worker “shortage,” where the demand for care exceeds the supply, leading to long waiting times for care and difficulties for parents in maintaining work. In many cases, the constraint is that childcare centers have difficulty attracting enough workers to provide care for children. For economists, this presents a puzzle: why are wages unable to adjust to attract enough workers to meet demand? We shed light on this issue by using exogenous variation in wages paid to entry-level childcare workers at Army Childcare Development Centers (CDCs) to understand the extent to which childcare worker hiring, turnover, and quality responds to an increase in the offered wage.

We exploit the introduction of Executive Order 14003, which set a $15 minimum wage for federal workers beginning in January 2022. This EO increased pay for entry-level childcare workers across all Army location, but the size of the wage increase varied widely by post depending on pre-EO wages. We therefore employ a difference-in-difference estimation strategy comparing changes in employment outcomes between posts which experienced a large increase in the wage to those which experienced a small increase in the wage.

Preliminary results confirm that this minimum wage led to a meaningful increase in workers’ wages which varies across location. Consistent with prior evidence from the private sector, this increase in wages increased wages led to increased employment. However, this increase in employment occurs only among part-time workers. Further, this increase in employment is driven by an increase in hiring rather than a decrease in departures.

An increase in hiring, but not reduction in departures suggests that non-pecuniary factors may substantively influence direct childcare workers’ employment decisions. To address this possibility, we are designing a survey to contextualize the value of wage and non-wage benefits for direct childcare workers to identify which amenities best complement wage policies to reduce turn-over.

We also use childcare accreditation data to explore the effect of worker-child ratios on constructed measures of childcare quality. Preliminary findings suggest that lower worker to child ratios result in more consistent and higher quality care for toddlers.

Together, these findings providing insight into strategies for improving the childcare infastructure available to active-duty servicemembers and their families. Improved family friendly infastructure has the potential to attract and more effectively retain a strong military workforce.

Author