Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Open for business? A longitudinal study of predictable scheduling preemption laws and entrepreneurial activity

Friday, November 6, 8:30 to 10:00am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Boston University

Abstract

Entrepreneurial activity is one of a region’s most valuable natural resources, positively correlated with job creation and economic growth, and negatively associated with community poverty. States promote entrepreneurial and small-business activity through legislative actions such as favorable tax laws, direct funding, removal of regulations, or preemption laws that restrict regulations perceived as burdensome to businesses. 

Within the last decade, state legislatures have been increasingly passing preemption laws, reducing the power of local governments. These laws are often promoted as business-friendly measures to nurture small businesses and the local economy. Preemption laws may lower regulatory burdens for organizations as well as signal to the business community that the state is committed to protecting business leaders’ autonomy and is in effect “open for business.” However, previous research indicates such preemption laws can carry costs such as alienating city leadership, constraining public policy, and limiting constituent responsiveness at the local level. Despite their widespread use, the efficacy of labor preemption laws is largely untested. Our research fills a gap in the literature by assessing the relationship between a business-friendly predictable scheduling preemption law and entrepreneurial activity.

This exploratory study uses twelve years of longitudinal data collected from several independent data sources including the Kauffman Indicators of Entrepreneurship, The U.S. Census, U.S. Bureau of Economic Activity, the U.S. Department of Labor and the Federal Reserve Bank, between 2010 and 2021. We constructed a difference-in-difference model to examine the relationship between state sponsored predictable schedule preemptive legislation and five measures of new business success including the (a) rate of new employer business, b) rate of new entrepreneurs, c) rate of new employer business actualization, d) average number of jobs created by new employer firms and e) one-year survival rates of new employers. 

Our findings suggest there is no association between predictable scheduling preemption laws and the creation or stability of new businesses in the region. In an OLS regression with fixed state and year effects and clustered standard errors, we observe no significant effect of predictable schedule preemption laws on any of our entrepreneurial activity indicators. Furthermore, in a difference-in-difference estimation, the effects of predictable scheduling preemption laws are not significant predictors of entrepreneurial activity. Robustness tests including the removal of Covid-19 pandemic years (2020 and 2021), attenuation of missing data, and placebo testing do not yield a significant change in results.  

Despite proponents' claims that predictable scheduling preemption will bring business and economic growth to a state, we do not observe that the adoption of one of these preemptive laws has any effect on entrepreneurial activity within a state. Even if passing such a law is value signaling, we find no indication that business respond to those signals. Therefore, policymakers considering one of these laws should question their effectiveness and balance the desire to encourage business in their state with the benefits of local government autonomy and local relationships with business.

Author