Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
Government organizations face a growing challenge of maintaining reliable program performance in the face of adverse external shocks, such as budgetary crises (Lee and Chen 2022), natural disasters (Meier, O’Toole, and Hicklin 2010), and the COVID-19 pandemic (Schomaker and Bauer 2020). Although much is known regarding how exogenous negative performance shocks adversely impact government administration (Flink 2018; Jeong and Song 2025), relatively little is known regarding how organizational characteristics can blunt the force of such negative shocks. Existing research often invokes broad concepts such as “administrative capacity (McCrea 2020)” or “managerial quality (Meier and O’Toole 2002)” as a buffering mechanism against poor performance during times of tumult. These studies, however, tend to focus either on high-level indicators, such as the attributes of top administrators, for example superintendents’ salary or their networking activities (Meier and O’Toole 2002), or on overly broad agency-level attributes, such as central office staffing ratios, the number of frontline workers, or state-wide quality of management systems (Flink and Chen 2021; McCrea 2020; Meier, et al. 2010). Because these concepts and corresponding measures relate to the organizational in global terms, they are unable to pinpoint the precise mechanism that represents the actual buffering device. This limitation is an important dilemma in public administration and management research given that buffering the technical core of service production lies at the heart of theoretical explanations of how administrative capacity mitigates the effects of exogenous shocks (Thompson 1967).
We argue that the caliber of task-specific staff expertise directly responsible for administering a particular government program is an effective mechanism to buffer against performance shocks. Using a rich panel data set on state unemployment insurance programs (UIPs) in the American states, coupled with causal-based time series intervention statistical methods, we demonstrate that this mechanism substantially reduces the adverse performance consequences of the COVID crisis on a non-routinized set of program eligibility tasks. Further, we show that these performance buffering effects are neither attributable to amount of unit-level staffing resources dedicated to these program management tasks, nor by broader agency-level characteristics. Instead, our study is able to isolate the impact of the caliber of staff expertise as the key mechanism sustaining performance under conditions of disruption.
More broadly, our study opens up the ‘black box’ of administrative capacity by showing that organizational resilience depends not on general capacity alone or solely on managerial quality, but the caliber of unit-level administrative staff expertise serves as an indispensable bulwark for the performance of skill-based administrative activities in times of crisis. Methodologically, linking unit-level staff expertise to task-specific performance outcomes avoids cross-level inference problems and enables direct tests of competing buffering mechanisms at both the unit and agency levels. The longitudinal structure of the data further allows for an analysis of dynamic effects, showing that the buffering role of staff expertise is most pronounced at the onset of crisis conditions, when performance disruptions are most severe.