Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

What's in a Mane?: Appearance Norms and Racialized Hair Bias

Saturday, November 7, 8:30 to 10:00am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Fairfield

Abstract

The existing literature on discrimination predominantly identifies bias through fixed markers, such as names on resumes or facial features. But many markers that shape daily experiences—how one speaks, dresses, or wears their hair—are mutable to varying degrees. Where conforming to dominant group norms carries economic returns (Akerlof & Kranton, 2000), these traits generate recurring private costs that studies focused on discrete episodes like hiring and lending do not capture. We provide direct evidence on these costs, focusing on hair, a trait where conformity costs are observable, large, and extend beyond pecuniary margins.

Hair texture—whether strands are straight, wavy, curly, or kinky—is immutable, yet hair style can be continuously altered using chemicals, heat, and accessories, often in ways central to self-expression, cultural identity, and religious practice. Bias against the naturally kinky texture of populations of African origin dates to the Transatlantic Slave Trade. Mainstream norms that view natural curly/kinky hair as inappropriate for the workplace impose substantial private costs: Black Americans spend about a 30% higher share of their income, and roughly 64 more hours—8 work days—per year on personal grooming relative to their white counterparts. Hair straightening also carries health risks, including cancer-related ones. These costs primarily fall on women, but young Black men also face penalties, such as school or sports suspensions for dreadlocks.

We conduct incentive-compatible, pre-registered experiments to assess appearance norms in academia. We pay special attention to STEM fields given that they are critical for innovation and productivity growth. University students (N=504) and a representative sample of US adults (N=2,424) each rated 32 headshots of hypothetical professor candidates on professionalism, competence, and agreeableness. The photos feature four models—a Black woman, a white woman, a Black man, and a white man. To encourage honest answers, we tell respondents they can win a $100 bonus for correctly predicting how university staff rated the same photos, making it safer to share views they might otherwise hold back.We find that hair bias is pronounced, intersectional, and involves non-pecuniary costs. Relative to straightened hair, wearing one's natural curly/kinky texture carries larger penalties for Black women than white women, primarily in perceived professionalism and competence. For Black men, racialized penalties concentrate in agreeableness. Smiling attenuates these racialized penalties, suggesting that Black candidates must actively project warmth that white candidates are not expected to supply––an asymmetric burden of emotional labor.

While our study leverages the clean identification hairstyle affords, it speaks to a broader class of malleable identity markers that individuals alter to conform to mainstream norms at ongoing private cost (e.g., accent code-switching by immigrants). Because these costs recur in daily life rather than at discrete episodes like hiring, they fall largely outside the existing literature's focus, implying that current estimates understate the welfare toll of discrimination. Our findings also inform ongoing U.S. legal discourse on extending protected status to hair texture as a feature of race.

Coauthor: Jeffrey Shrader
Full paper link: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/oa7svllz6pdmhr3ms8rkr/ErdaShrader-What-s-in-a-mane.pdf?rlkey=lzppe9vo2hibhr9tcxzvva9cc&e=1&st=g0o9hcsb&dl=0

References:
Akerlof, G.A., & Kranton, R.E.(2000). Economics and identity. Quarterly Journal ofEconomics,115(3),715–753.

Author