Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Do Public Schools Improve Academic Performance in Anticipation of Universal School Choice?

Friday, November 6, 10:15 to 11:45am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: Arlington

Abstract

Most evidence on how public schools respond to private school choice comes from targeted voucher programs. Arkansas’s LEARNS Act of 2023 created a universal education savings account, the Education Freedom Account (EFA), and phased in eligibility over three years, so public schools knew for two years that universal choice was coming while few of their students could yet leave. We ask whether schools facing more potential competition improved more during those two years. Arkansas has few private schools, and most of them are in and around cities, so counts of existing private schools mostly separate urban from rural schools. We therefore select measure of potential competition by the number of places of worship within a 10-minute drive of each public school as a headline measure. This competition measure serves as a proxy for the latent supply of, capacity for and interest in private schooling. We show that a standard deviation increase in competition measure is associated with 0.02 standard deviation higher achievement gains after LEARNS. The gain is concentrated in the most-exposed quarter of schools, a gain of similar size appears among urban schools alone, so it is not simply an urban–rural contrast, and it accrues to students who could not yet use an account. It is larger in charter and magnet schools, which already compete for students. Mathematics estimates are near zero but too imprecise to rule out effects of the ELA size. The evidence suggests that the prospect of universal choice may have raised achievement where potential competition was greatest.

Author