Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Teenage Births and Safety Net Generosity

Friday, November 6, 8:30 to 10:00am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 5th Floor, Room: Maine

Abstract

The teenage years are a critical period for human capital formation, during which policy environments may influence a range of outcomes with potentially long-lasting effects. In particular, teenage childbearing is strongly associated with lower educational attainment, weaker labor market attachment, and higher welfare dependency, making it a key margin through which early policy environments may shape long-run trajectories.

Over the past two decades, the United States has experienced a sustained decline in fertility, driven largely by reductions in teenage births. While widely viewed as a positive trend, descriptive evidence indicates that states with lower teenage birth rates coincide with more generous safety net programs. This pattern raises an important policy question: does welfare generosity causally affect teenage fertility and subsequent life-course outcomes?

This paper examines how exposure to welfare generosity during the teenage years affects the likelihood of teenage births, as well as subsequent educational attainment and labor market outcomes into early prime working age. We use individual-level data from the Current Population Survey (CPS) spanning 2003–2025 and construct a cohort-based measure of exposure to state-level welfare generosity during ages 15–18. Our empirical strategy exploits quasi-experimental variation in safety net generosity across states and cohorts, combining a cohort exposure design with state and cohort fixed effects to identify within-state policy changes over time. We focus on programs most relevant to households with teenage children, including Medicaid, tax credits, TANF, and SNAP. We further examine heterogeneity by socioeconomic characteristics and decompose exposure into major program components.

Our preliminary results indicate that the effects of safety net exposure on teenage childbearing are concentrated among the at-risk population. Restricting the sample to households below 200% of the Federal Poverty Line (FPL) yields a positive association between exposure to overall welfare generosity and teenage births, while estimates are larger in magnitude and statistically significant for the near-poor subgroup (second income quartile). We also document important heterogeneity across program components: exposure to food assistance and cash assistance operates in opposite directions, with food assistance generally associated with lower teenage birth rates among at-risk women, and cash assistance associated with higher rates. As a result, aggregating these components into a composite index attenuates the overall estimated effect toward zero. In contrast, estimates in the full sample (dominated by households with income above 200% FPL) are statistically indistinguishable from zero.

Overall, the findings contribute to ongoing discussions on declining fertility by emphasizing the role of early-life policy environments in shaping life-course decisions. In addition, they highlight the importance of accounting for interactions and potential dynamic responses across different types of assistance when evaluating long-run policy effects.

Author