Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Concussions and the Classroom: The Causal Effects of an Acute Health Shock on Student Schooling Outcomes

Saturday, November 7, 10:15 to 11:45am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 3rd Floor, Room: MIT

Abstract

This paper examines the impact of diagnosed concussions on academic performance and behavioral outcomes among high school students. Using rich administrative data from the Hawai‘i Department of Education linked to statewide student-athlete health and incident records, we estimate the causal effects of concussions using the Callaway–Sant’Anna doubly robust difference-in-differences framework and a comparison group of athletes who experience concussions at a later date. This approach allows us to account for staggered treatment timing while reducing bias from unobserved differences between students who experience concussions earlier versus later in their high school careers. We find little evidence that a single concussion produces sustained academic or behavioral impacts. Across specifications, estimates for first-time concussions are small and statistically indistinguishable from zero once pre-trends are accounted for. In contrast, cumulative exposure to two or more concussions generates sizable and persistent effects on student outcomes. Students with multiple concussions experience a 0.628 grade point decline in annual GPA, driven primarily by declines in mathematics course performance. We also find a 17.2 percentage point reduction in the likelihood of enrolling in at least one Advanced Placement course, suggesting a meaningful shift in academic track placement and course intensity following repeated injury. On the behavioral side, repeated concussions are associated with a 0.158 increase in disciplinary infractions, indicating worsening school engagement or conduct following cumulative exposure. These patterns are consistent with a non-linear relationship between concussion exposure and human capital formation, where isolated injuries may have limited long-term consequences but repeated neurological shocks lead to more persistent disruption. The results also highlight important heterogeneity in effects across academic domains, with math achievement appearing particularly sensitive to repeated concussive injury. More broadly, the findings illustrate how acute health shocks during adolescence can disrupt educational trajectories and shape human capital accumulation during a critical period of skill formation. Because concussions disproportionately occur in the context of school sports participation, the results also speak to the intersection of youth health policy, school-based athletics, and educational equity. The evidence suggests that policy attention may be most effectively directed toward preventing repeat injuries and strengthening monitoring and return-to-learn protocols after initial concussion events.

Author