Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Brazilian Supreme Court and Social Policies: A Judicial Review Analysis

Sat, October 2, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

What is the Brazilian Supreme Court (STF) role in resolving social disputes after 1988? Brazil, like many Latin American countries, has gone through democratic waves and authoritarian periods in its history. The most recent democratic constitution provides an ideal scenario for the high demand for conflict resolution by the Judiciary: there is the construction of a strong and free Judiciary and many constitutionalized policies. The result is an increase in the role of the Supreme Court in national politics. In terms of social security (retirement, social assistance, and health rights) it is no different. The Court was called upon to decide on constitutional amendments that reformed social security policies over time. In order to understand the Judiciary's role in politics, there are models designed over the last decades to comprehend judicial behavior. However, it is understood that none of the models alone fully explains the role of a supreme court. Therefore, this research has considered the tactical balancing account thesis, which understands that the courts take into account several considerations when deciding, as the leading theory for the analysis. The content of 52 final decisions of appeals to the STF (recurso extraordinário) and direct actions of unconstitutionality (ADI) were analyzed using a qualitative exploratory method. The content analysis method was chosen to understand which type of considerations judges take into account when deciding social security policies. The software used in this research was MaxQDA. Each consideration was treated as a code: pragmatic, preference-driven, self-protective, support-building, deferential, and principled. They are part of the tactical balancing account theory. This research has concluded that the STF acts as validator of Executive’s and Legislative’s policies most of the time when it is provoked to decide about social security policies and the institutional context, the procedural rules, and the Justices background contribute to this role of the Court. However, the court may have different roles depending on the considerations it takes into account when it decides on social security rights. For example, the court also understands that people need to feel they have some possibility of winning a dispute against the government. This is also because they need to maintain a good image of the institution before society. Therefore, when the subject of the dispute is too sensitive for public opinion, the court tends to rule in favor of them.

Author