Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Protesting During the Covid: When Economic Deprivation Trumps Contagion Risk

Sun, October 3, 12:00 to 1:30pm PDT (12:00 to 1:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

When do people downplay mortality risk and take the streets? Although the COVID-19 outbreak has increased time spent indoors with lockdowns and home office practices, from the Black Lives Matter in the United States to the Free Fare Movement in Brazil, recent protests show that in some cases, people’s socioeconomic and political grievances may outweigh their concerns about contagion. Building on the cost of abstention theory by Aytaç and Stokes (Aytaç and Stokes 2018), this paper studies what brings people to take contentious collective action (CCA) when high mortality risk adds to the risk of repression. Using the cases of Bimeks workers in Turkey, we argue that although the pandemic has increased participation costs and has undercut protest diffusion to multiple cities and societal groups, it has failed to diminish the cost of abstention for the aggrieved; therefore, protest duration did not shorten. Protests sustain despite high contagion risk, because, conspicuous effects of economic deprivation (e.g., inability to provide for the family) and anger dwarf perceived costs of contagion by an invisible virus and of repression in the short run. We test this argument with an extension of the Aytaç-Stokes model and rich empirical evidence from semi-structured interviews and newspaper coverage of protests. This study, which combines the emotions and rational choice approaches, shows that participation costs for bystanders may have increased during the pandemic; but, abstention costs for initial protesters have increased even more due to economic slowdown, whereby neither repression nor contagion risk have weakened protesters’ resolve to continue CCA. These findings parallel the literature on protests under authoritarianisms, which contends that repression does not decrease CCA. Rather, repression towards aggrieved protesters strengthens intra-group solidarity and perceived unjustness of police violence, which sustain protests over days.

Authors