Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Liberal Pluralism in John Stuart Mill's Stationary State

Sun, October 3, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

John Stuart Mill’s brief, but puzzling, passage about the “stationary state” in his Principles of Political Economy has confounded commentators for nearly two centuries. In this remarkable account, Mill considered the concept of the zero-economic growth “stationary state”—the dreaded bane of classical political economy since Adam Smith—and reinterpreted it in laudatory terms as what one observer has called a “liberal utopia.” Commentators are divided, however, as to the central principle animating Mill’s case for the stationary state with it being seen variously as an argument for an ancient Aristotelian idea of happiness, for civic republicanism, for a version of proto-socialism, as a rejection of socialism on behalf of economic liberty, and as a revision of Ricardian economic theory.
In this paper I offer an alternative reading of Mill’s stationary state, one that emphasizes his intention to establish a normative economics that promotes liberal pluralism. In particular, I interpret Mill’s support for the ideal of zero-economic growth in terms of his concern to protect diversity of thought and lifestyle in liberal societies, diversity that he believed was endangered by the culturally and socially homogenizing effects of both laissez-faire capitalism and centralized socialism. Thus, the ideal of the stationary state characterized by economic equilibrium stands as a foundational principle in Mill’s account of the aspiration of liberalism to provide not only for individual intellectual, moral and aesthetic liberty, but also for the general material security of society.

Author