Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This paper considers how paramilitaries during the Colombian civil war attempted to exert different forms of social control through gendered violence. More specifically, it explores the relationship between homophobic violence and sexual violence through a mixed-methods, case studies analysis of two different paramilitary groups operating in Colombia during the height of the paramilitary incursion (1980s-2000s). In the first case study in Magdalena Medio, I argue that the paramilitary group did not establish a positive relationship between homophobic violence and sexual violence because their attempted social order relied on community support. Thus, they violently targeted LGBT people, considered as a deviant threat, but banned the use of rape. I label this form of social control— which relies on more persuasive, legitimizing violence— the ‘public good’ thesis. In the second case study in Montes de María, I argue that the paramilitary group did pursue a positive relationship between homophobic violence and sexual violence because their attempted social order relied on the complete domination of the local population. I label this form of social control—which relies on horrific, ‘spectacular’ forms of violence—the ‘violent coercion’ thesis. These different forms of social control, thus, are the result of differing paramilitary strategies concerning the relationship of homophobic violence and sexual violence. These arguments conform to established thought that the relationship between these two forms of violence would depend on the nature of the armed actor, as well as local armed actor-civilian relations. These arguments challenge, however, the understated assumption in conflict dynamics research that varying repertoires of gendered violence produce similar results. With this exercise, I demonstrate that there is nuance in the coercive potential of different gendered forms of violence and analyzing their variation betters our understanding of the productive and persuasive capacities of violence during war, thereby revealing new logics.