Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Environmental Injustice in Clean Water Act Enforcement

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Decades of interdisciplinary research has documented that people of color and low-income in the United States experience disproportionate environmental burdens. The foundational work in this “environmental justice” literature focuses on the location or siting of noxious facilities, such as hazardous waste landfills (Bullard 1990; Mohai and Saha 2006), with other work also showing race- and income-based disparities in exposure to pollution (Ash and Boyce 2018; Li et al. 2019; Schaider et al. 2017; Stillo and MacDonald Gibson 2019).

Another stream of related research examines disparities in government regulatory enforcement, which may cause, or at least exacerbate, inequitable spatial patterns of pollution sources and environmental exposures. Although many U.S. federal pollution control laws impose uniform, national standards, enforcement of these standards can vary substantially across the country. This variation is amplified by the lead role that state governments play in environmental enforcement, and that fact that states pursue their enforcement with varying degrees of effort (Konisky and Woods 2017). Empirical studies have examined whether the frequency or number of inspections are associated with the demographic characteristics of the areas in which regulated facilities are located, as well the stringency of punitive actions taken to bring firms violating the law back into compliance. In this work, scholars have demonstrated race and income-based disparities in regulatory enforcement of air pollution control requirements (Konisky 2009; Konisky and Reenock 2013, 2018), water pollution and drinking water standards (Switzer and Teodoro 2018), and hazardous waste handling and disposal standards (Opp 2012; Spina 2015). Findings from this scholarship is not homogenous, but suggests meaningful disparities in environmental enforcement.

Studies analyzing regulatory enforcement disparities have employed statistical models to either estimate the probability that a federal or state agency performs an enforcement action (e.g., conducts an inspection, issues a notice of violation) or the total number of such actions over some duration of time. In this study, we adopt an alternative approach that measures the duration of time it takes for government officials to inspect a facility to determine if there is a difference based on the demographics of the community in which the facility is located. We believe this new approach provides a meaningful way to understand the relative prioritization of government environmental enforcement efforts.

Government inspectors are constrained in available time and resources for performing compliance monitoring, meaning choices have to be made about where to invest their effort. Given the prior literature showing disparities in environmental enforcement, we posit that there is likely to be more time between inspections for facilities located in Black, Hispanic, and high-poverty areas as compared to white and lower-poverty areas. Specifically, we analyze the duration of response time, conditional on the compliance status of a regulated facility, which enables us to determine whether the time to inspection is associated with community characteristics. Slower response toward facilities that are failing to meet their performance standards potentially means diminished environmental quality, which may create risks to human and ecological health. If government delay in response more likely in some communities rather than others, this will produce geographic disparities in environmental quality, and to the extent that these disparities are based on race or income, they generate environmental injustice concerns.

To investigate the relationship between inspections response time and the demographic characteristics of the communities that host regulated facilities, we study administrative data from state implementation of the U.S. Clean Water Act (CWA). State enforcement of CWA is a useful setting for this analysis because there are thousands of major sources of water pollution regulated throughout the United States and because the EPA maintains detailed data on the both the compliance status of these sources and the specific dates in which they receive compliance monitoring inspections. We couple this administrative data with demographic information around CWA facilities to analyze the relationship between response time and community characteristics. Estimating event history models, we find that state regulators’ inspection response time to noncompliant facilities varies over the demographics of the community. State regulators respond slower to noncompliant facilities located in communities that have higher percentages of poor and Hispanic citizens. With respect to Black communities, state regulators’ response time to noncompliant facilities is no different than compliant facilities.

Authors