Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Support for Violent versus Non-Violent Strategies in the Palestinian Territories

Fri, October 1, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Existing literature has documented at great length the capacity needed for nonviolent versus violent action; nonviolence requires large-scale societal buy-in, and a critical mass to deter state backlash, whereas violence can be undertaken with fewer people and does not necessitate societal support. In spite of this rich body of literature, we know less about how preferences for nonviolence or violence are determined at the individual level. This paper argues that strategy preference is motivated by an individual’s assessment of their society’s cohesion, and thus their society’s capacity for nonviolence versus violence. Preferences for non-violent strategies are determined to some degree by high social cohesion, which gives people a greater guarantee that there will be capacity for such a strategy - as the literature on this subject already confirms. However, preferences for violent strategies are not always determined by social cohesion, or lack thereof. The relationship is in fact nonlinear; violence may be a legitimate strategy preference, not an anarchic reaction that societies “default” to when there are no other options.

The paper examines this dynamic within the case of Palestine. Strong social cohesion during particular time periods has been key in mobilizing Palestinians in support of non-violent strategies, and in the ability of Palestinians to overcome collective action problems. But Palestinian society today has undergone immense transformation, particularly after the 1994 Oslo Accords; Palestinians are more fragmented, demobilized, and politically stagnant than ever before. Social cohesion has been significantly damaged. Moreover, the institutions which once organized Palestinians no longer exist, at the same time that Israeli repression, surveillance, and restrictions have become much more severe. Thus, this leads to the question: will Palestinians resist using violent means, now that social cohesion is weak? Or will the high cost of repression deter violent resistance? To understand the future trajectory of Palestinian resistance, we must assess preference formation and the impact of social cohesion, or lack thereof, on individual decision-making. The paper uses survey data and analysis as well as experimental methods to answer these questions.

Author