Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Leadership in Judicial Decision-Making

Sat, October 2, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

One of the consistent conclusions in the literature on decision-making on lower federal courts is that judges decide cases cooperatively. A number of studies report low levels of dissent on circuit courts. This is caused in part by judges being more attuned to the preferences of their fellow judges. These conclusions, however, are more tenuous when examining the behavior of district court judges serving by designation on appellate panels. Further, recent work on three-judge district court panels suggests that what appears to be cooperative decision-making may actually be the influence of a single judge serving on these panels. Other research examining the roles of sex and race reaches similar conclusions regarding the influence of particular judges. Combining all of these findings leads us to question whether the oft-reported narrative of cooperative decision-making by judicial panels misses the influence of particular jurists within the judiciary. Using various datasets, we examine the argument that certain characteristics (e.g., potential nomination to Supreme Court, being a district court judge) lead to judges having greater or less influence over the behavior of judges with whom they serve.

Authors