Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Amor Mundi as Capability to Transcend: Arendt’s Conception of the Human (Pre-Recorded)

Fri, October 1, 12:00 to 1:30pm PDT (12:00 to 1:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

The significance of the phenomenological conception of the human, in Arendt, is that this way of understanding helps us distinguish human life—between birth and death—as worldly events that constitute the space of appearances, from that of the earthly ever-recurring cycle of nature. To interrupt the cycle, as a way of transcending, human beings erect a world upon the earth and take care of it via human capacities: labor, work and action. Every act, seen not from the perspective of the agent but the process, appears as a miracle, an interruption of automatic unstoppable cosmic movement (BPF 150). Yet, “to act is to err, to go astray.” (LM 184-194) Thus, to some extent, erring also names the inherent characteristics of humans who act: uncertainty (unpredictable and irreversible) and frailty. Equally dangerous, the human capacity to act in modern science—to begin anew and end uncertainly—may push us into an irreversible and irremediable “process of no return.” (HC 231-2)
In this regard, I look to Hannah Arendt’s concept of amor mundi (love of the world) to further explore the world-building capacities of human, who are constitutively prone to error (falter and stumble). This is significant as ‘love’ leads back to the question of the nobodyness (“Why is there anybody and rather than nobody?”) as a quintessential question of the human (“What does it mean to be human?”) in Arendt’s political thought, when she claims: “He who does not love and desire at all is a nobody.” (LSA 20) In view of this, I look to amor mundi to examine Arendt’s account of loving capability for two reasons. First, love is only ‘worldly’ when it “rests on being of the world (de mundo).” Second, only through loving the world, can human beings explicitly be “at home in the world.” (LSA, 67)
The gist of the dialectics of amor mundi lies in the fact that, the world, we humans build and sustain together, is to be shared, but the first-hand experience of the world is not that demonstrable and sharable, as Michaele L. Ferguson suggests. As Roger Berkowitz points out, Arendt’s amor mundi does not designate ‘uncritical acceptance nor contemptuous rejection’, but ‘unwavering facing up to and comprehending’ what is going on as it is. Guided by this spirit, I emphasize the “unwavering facing up to” the importance of the indispensable boundaries and fences in loving the world. Building on existing scholarship on Arendt’s conception of love, I draw attention to an often-overlooked aspect of amor mundi: it is human beings who are capable of loving the world by way of transcending.
To tackle with this interpretive goal, certain theoretical puzzles are to be dealt with within Arendt’s idiosyncratic thought. Firstly, the translation of amor mundi is a contradiction in terms: insofar as, “love, in its very nature, is unworldly,” Arendt sometimes suggests it as anti-political (HC 242). So, theoretically, to what extent is worldly love even possible for us to comprehend? Adding to the complexity, how do we interpret Arendt’s rather ‘personal’ message about love: “the only kind of love” acknowledged is the love toward persons, rather than any collective groups or people? (JW, 466-467) Further, to what extent is amor mundi meaningful and achievable in a political and social context? Finally, how do we justify Arendt’s eulogy that love is “a power of the universe, insofar the universe is alive.” (DTB 372)
In response to these interpretive difficulties, I demonstrate that, love transcends by way of human experiences and human capability. On one hand, as exquisitely rare experiences of love, different people have different ‘feelings’, and different way of presenting the intricacy and subtlety of loving feelings. Thus, by loving the beloved ones, human beings can carry across (transcend) the invisible and the metaphysically indemonstrable into something that can be, but not necessarily need to be, demonstrated or visualized (with metaphors). On the other hand, as an exclusively world-building capability, love has the power to carry over (transcend) the earthly finitude of human existence, by natality, freedom, forgiving and promising, etc. In view of this, love is a ‘power’, rather than a ‘feeling’ or ‘romance.’ (DTB 372) Since love “possesses an unequaled power of self-revelation and an unequalled clarity of vision for the disclosure of who,” regardless what “qualities and shortcomings,” “achievements, failings and transgressions” the beloved person may have. (DTB 372) Both experiences and capability of love are existentially and ontologically rooted within human existence as capacity to world and transcend; and both logically and constitutively entail certain ‘cognitive’ boundaries or ‘essential’ fences over which human beings are granted the access to carry across or carry over.

Author