Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Carrot or the Stick? U.S. Presidents and Counterterrorism Tools

Sun, October 3, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Different approaches to tackle overseas terrorist threats are associated with a variety of pros and cons, as well as varying levels of effectiveness. U.S Presidents have a wide array of policy tools at their disposal which they can use to mitigate terrorist threats emanating from other countries. These can generally be categorized as punitive tools, such as economic sanctions or arms embargoes, or non-punitive options such as military assistance and training. Yet, the factors which account for governments’ counterterrorism policy choices remain underexplored. To shed light on the factors that explain counterterrorism choices in the post 9/11 era, we examine the policies and tools adopted by President Obama and President Trump to thwart transnational threats from violent extremist organizations. Within this study, we explore the extent to which Presidents’ punitive and non-punitive choices remained a) aligned with the policy choices of the Bush administration which initiated the War on Terror, b) remained consistent with their national political party platforms and/or c) responded to changing patterns of transnational terrorism, and/or attacks against US interests overseas. By comparing Presidents’ policy choices across these three dimensions, our study yields important insights regarding the extent to which choices of counterterrorism tools are shaped by path dependency, party platforms or the broader security environment.

Authors