Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Coordinating Violence in Decentralized Protests: Evidence from Hong Kong in 2019

Sun, October 3, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

In the 2019 Hong Kong Anti-Extradition Protests (HKAEP), leaderless protesters demonstrated an ability to escalate and de-escalate violent tactics collectively, despite the absence of an organizing structure. For instance, after the protesters attracted condemnations for restraining a Chinese reporter during a demonstration, they returned to the scene peacefully and apologized for excessive coercion. Conventional scholarship on social movements tends to recognize the hierarchical organization as a prerequisite of collective tactics. As such, existing studies either consider decentralized movements as lacking measured strategies or examine leaderless protesters’ rationality merely at the individual level. Thus, previous research fails to explain how coordinated actions emerge in a decentralized context, as in the Hong Kong case.

This study explains the puzzle of coordination in the HKAEP by answering a two-part question: how did the leaderless protesters forge collective strategies, and what were the shared motivations that drove the protesters to cooperate? This paper argues that, firstly, Hong Kong protesters negotiated general consensuses on violent tactics via a social media platform, LIHKG, which enabled demonstrators to cultivate a sense of community by sharing their experiences and thoughts during the movement. Also, LIHKG’s algorithm allowed protesters to survey other participants’ opinions on action proposals, providing a de facto mechanism for collective decision-making. Secondly, to explain protesters’ shared motivations to adjust violent tactics, this study investigates four factors: strategic intensification, international support, mass mobilization, and structural politics. I find that violent escalations resulted from protesters’ strategic decision to intensify challenges against the government, given their frustration with moderate tactics. Nevertheless, since the structural politics of the authoritarian regime imposed substantial difficulties on the pro-democracy movement, the protesters refrained from undisciplined escalations to maintain international support. They also occasionally de-escalated their use of violence to preserve the movement’s ability of mass mobilization.

I conducted mixed-method content analysis based on the 1,200 most influential LIHKG posts from the 80 days when discussions about violent tactics were most intense. If LIHKG facilitated coordination over collective strategies, the mechanisms should be most salient in these posts. Using statistics of LIHKG discussions provided by scholars at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, I identified the days with the highest daily density and daily total number of violence-related posts as the periods of intense debates on movement strategy. I scraped the 15 most popular posts from each selected day and coded them with seven themes of interest in this study. In this way, I created a dataset of 80 observations - each with seven variables of scale 0 to 15 - using each theme’s daily frequency. I conducted regression tests to measure the correlations between escalation/de-escalation proposals and hypothesized factors of influence. I also drew upon post-level textual analysis to interpret the outcomes of the regressions. In light of the findings, quantitative and qualitative examinations of LIHKG discussions consistently support my arguments.

This paper reveals that collective strategies in a decentralized movement emerge upon two conditions: social media communications that facilitate coordination among leaderless protesters and shared motivations driving them to cooperate. This study contributes to existing scholarship by identifying the conditions that enable collective strategies – usually thought to be associated with organized movements – to emerge in decentralized protests. Protesters’ use of social media and their shared motivations for strategic adjustments are not unique to conflicts in Hong Kong. Therefore, similar decentralized coordination may occur in other movements across the globe. Understanding the possible emergence of collective strategies in decentralized protests may open up new directions for social movements literature and inform the international community’s policy choices.

Author