Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Second United States Catholic President

Fri, October 1, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Introduction: The Catholic Church has always worked politically to advance its religious beliefs to serve the common good. In the United States it has advanced a political agenda that has supported a pro-life stance, traditional family values, school choice, an option for the poor, and immigration reform. It has called on its adherents to be politically involved, morally consistent and coherent, and to bear public witness to these principles. However, this has led to a bifurcation between Catholic religious beliefs and its pragmatic political practices, often challenging Catholic politicians to choose and/or seek a compromise between their Church’s religious demands and the shifting political values of an evolving multi-cultural, religiously pluralistic state in America.
Research Question: How, then, has Joe Biden managed to overcome this problem and become the only Catholic to become President of the United States since John Kennedy in l960?
Hypothesis: This paper will argue that during the intervening years between the elections of Kennedy and Biden, the Catholic Church has continued to support its religious principles, but Catholic politicians, such as Joe Biden, have evolved politically, reflected social changes in the United States, and espoused more secular views than their Church.
Research Design: The significance of this quandary will be examined through the political responses of both the U. S. Catholic hierarchy and Catholic candidates for high civil office on several specific cases and issues that have exacerbated this problem. They include the Supreme Court’s decisions in Roe v Wade and Obergefell v Hodges, the political rise of American Evangelicals, changes in the traditional Catholic political coalition, and the myth of the “Catholic vote.”
Analysis: Making difficult choices and/or compromises between their religion and their politics has led Catholic politicians to pursue the presidency very differently than John Kennedy did more than a half century ago. This paper will analyze first, how political decisions, specifically in the case of Joe Biden, have impacted both the Democratic and Republican Parties, their bases, and traditional coalitions. Second, it will examine how Joe Biden’s election might alter the relationship between the US Catholic hierarchy and the new President, as well as its relevance and impact on Church-State inter-actions. Third, it will also consider more broadly what a Catholic presidency could mean for public policy and legislation in the United States in the future.

Author