Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Nomos Basileus: Customary Authority and Socratic Rhetoric in Plato's Symposium

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

This article brings to light a dimension of Socratic virtue that is often overlooked. Scholars frequently eulogize Socrates, not only as the man most liberated from convention, but also as a philanthropist who would liberate others from its grip, the better to lead the philosophic life.These views have their strengths, but they tend to minimize how the Platonic Socrates, at least on the surface, allies himself with convention, against those who prematurely or recklessly claim to throw it off. In this article, I intend to expose this side of Socrates by emphasizing the resilient and ironic presence of custom and convention in the Symposium, a dialogue whose setting would lead one would expect an atmosphere of lawless—if urbane—debauchery. I demonstrate how Socrates himself protects custom in the face of this expectation, so that he may reconcile those who uphold convention with philosophy. This strategy deserves recognition, not only because it enriches scholarly understanding, but also because its lessons remain pertinent. It remains impossible and dangerous to erase custom from the political chalkboard. The philosopher who tries to do so necessarily futilely endangers both herself and philosophy. I argue that Plato maintains a critical distance from Socrates, and, having seen how edifying non-philosophers ultimately cost Socrates his life, contends that it is too large a risk to take. I therefore conclude by illuminating how the Symposium conveys a message of love from Plato to philosophers everywhere: know your limitations; you are too special to die at the hands of conventionalism.

Author