Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Does Naming and Shaming Influence State Human Rights Practices?

Tue, September 28, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

To what extent does naming and shaming influence state human rights practices? While many Western countries and international human rights organizations embrace shaming as a strategy to deter and limit human rights abuses, prior empirical work on the effects of naming and shaming have shown mixed results. In this article, we take a new approach to examining how naming and shaming influences state human rights practices. First, we use human rights reports and automatic text analysis to develop two new cross-national measures of human rights shaming. One focuses on shaming activities by Amnesty International, while the other focuses on shaming activities by the U.S. government. After validating this measure, we model the effects of shaming on human rights practices. Our results show that while AI’s shaming activities do not improve human rights practices, US shaming is positively associated with the human rights conditions. Our measures and results contribute to the growing literatures on human rights, international organizations, and foreign policy.

Authors