Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Mayoral Leadership and Immigrant Sanctuary in San Francisco

Wed, September 29, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

This paper offers a grounded theoretical analysis of immigrant sanctuary policies and practices in San Francisco between 1985 and 2018 to clarify the role of mayors in developing, defending, and adjusting city efforts to shield undocumented immigrants from increasingly aggressive federal immigration enforcement policies. While scholars have pointed out that individual personality and capabilities, institutional structure, and local context are important drivers of mayoral leadership, I rely on assorted qualitative data to make the case that also the multi-level political context of U.S. immigration policy is a key determinant for how mayors address immigration issues locally. In particular, I highlight two strategies that San Francisco mayors have used to influence sanctuary policies and practices while navigating ongoing federal scrutiny of the city’s lenient treatment of undocumented immigrants. When mayors sought to strengthen or further institutionalize immigrant sanctuary into local government practices, they embraced facilitative leadership strategies characterized by active collaboration with other governmental and nongovernmental actors. When they sought to dial back sanctuary for fear of losing critical federal funding or exposing city sanctuary policies to potentially devastating anti-sanctuary litigation, they instead relied on executive leadership strategies characterized by top-down decision-making and mayoral insulation from other governmental and nongovernmental actors.

Author