Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Does the dissemination of fake news affect electoral outcomes? An increasing number of studies have examined how exposure to fake news affects voters’ perception on candidates and electoral behavior. Typically, previous work uses post-election surveys and analyzes associations between respondents’ disposition to believe fake news and actual voting behavior. They mostly find that fake news does affect voting behavior to varying degrees. However, the survey-based observational studies do not convincingly show that these changes were actually caused by the dissemination of fake news. To verify the causal effect of fake news, we need a counterfactual, that is, how they would have voted without being exposed to such false information. To fill this gap, we conduct an experiment with an internet survey by focusing on the 2018 presidential election of Mexico.
This case provides us with an ideal setting in which to examine whether the dissemination of fake news caused the changes in voting behavior. During the election campaign, Ricardo Anaya, who was a candidate of the National Action Party (PAN), was fiercely accused of the alleged involvement in a money laundering scandal. Andrés Manuel López Obrador from the National Regeneration Movement (MORENA) won a land slide victory in the election. After the election, however, Anaya’s innocence was officially acknowledged by the public authorities and a major newspaper. We exploit this unique opportunity to see if voters would regret their vote choice and change their behavior knowing that the information about Anaya’s scandal was false. Specifically, our experiment uses two information stimuli: public disclosures of information that Anaya was innocent by a major newspaper and the supreme electoral court.
Our multivariate analysis demonstrates that the retraction of fake news caused post-election regret and an intention to switch their vote choice to Anaya among Obrador voters who trusted the media, but did not affect voters associated with a high degree of internal political efficacy. The finding suggests that those voters’ decision was distorted by the spreading of false information about Anaya. Although the effect was not large enough to change the winner of the presidential election, the electoral consequence of fake news was not negligible.