Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How Diverse Is Religion’s Influence on Intractable Conflicts?

Tue, September 28, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

All conflicts, irrespective of being inter-state or intra-state are costly and risky. They, however, vary in their intensity and persistence. While some conflicts escalate into violence and last for longer periods, others are short-term and less intense. Understanding this variation across conflicts and the reasons behind it has been the frontier of research over the last decade. This paper builds on this literature and grapples with the dynamics of intractable conflicts, especially those fought on religious grounds. Traditional conflict resolution techniques such as negotiation and mediation fail to manage or resolve such conflicts. Hensel and Mitchell (2005) argue that issues with greater intangible salience are difficult to be resolved peacefully. Disagreements over religion, ethnicity and historical significance are believed to be among those intangible items, meaning they are difficult or impossible to define, understand and divide. Such intangible issues result in indivisible bargains, which subsequently lead to intense, persistent and hence, intractable conflicts.

The existing literature demonstrates the potential of religion to promote violence, conflict and revolution (Rapoport 1991, Girard 1977, Juergensmeyer 1991, Huntington 1993, 1996). The belief that conflicts fought over religion are less likely to be resolved through negotiated settlement is reflected in the works of Hassner (2009), Svensson (2007) and Toft (2006), among others. To date, however, little research has examined the conditions under which religion – both as an identity and as an issue – lead to conflict and renders them intractable. Moreover, most studies compare religious and non-religious conflicts but overlook the variations within religious conflicts, especially among different religious causes and their effects on conflict intractability. This study argues that it is crucial to disaggregate different types of religious issues to assess their influence on conflict dynamics. Operationalizing intractable conflicts in terms of their intensity and duration, I contend that different religious issues affect conflict intractability differently.

To this end, I plan to concentrate on conflicts between groups subscribing to two world religions – Hinduism and Islam – and to focus on these conflicts within India. To understand how the deep-seated religious cleavage between Hindus and Muslims germinate violence resulting in intense and persistent conflicts, I carry out a quantitative analysis of conflicts between Hindus and Muslims as manifest through incessant riots since Indian independence in 1947, approximately since post-World War II. Using the Varshney-Wilkinson Dataset on Hindu-Muslim Violence in India (1950-1995), I code religious issues into four different types – (1) desecration/destruction of sacred sites, (2) religious festivities, (3) animal slaughter and (4) enforcement of religious symbols. I argue that compared to religious issues like Public rituals/festivities; Animal Slaughter and Enforcement of Religious Symbols, any issue that involves sacred sites will result in the most intractable conflicts. I, specifically hypothesize:

Hypothesis 1: In conflicts between different religious groups (based on identity), conflicts over sacred sites result in greater conflict intensity than conflicts over animal slaughter; public rituals/festivities and enforcement of religious symbols.

Hypothesis 2: In conflicts between different religious groups (based on identity), conflicts over sacred sites result in greater conflict duration than conflicts over animal slaughter; public rituals/festivities and enforcement of religious symbols.

I believe that this paper relates to APSA’s conference theme, ‘Promoting Pluralism’ as it incorporates various dynamics of conflict, measured in terms of intensity and duration along with an analysis of antagonism among diverse faith traditions – Hinduism and Islam in the context of the South Asian region, particularly India.

Author