Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Keeping it Professional: Lexical Diversity and Bureaucratizing National Security

Sun, October 3, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Scholars of foreign policy and International Relations have long debated the importance of bureaucracy to decision-making and the dysfunctions that accompany bureaucratic methods. Far less attention has been given to bureaucratization as an outcome. This paper analyzes when and how national security functions become bureaucratized in the first place. To do so, we introduce the concept of lexical diversity—that is, the complexity and variety of words used in text—as both a constitutive element of and proxy measure for the professionalization of governmental bureaucracies. Building on a novel data source and new measurement strategies, we trace the uneven bureaucratization of national security intelligence in the U.S. government. The paper’s empirical focus is analysis of a dataset of a unique corpus: the raw text of seventeen years of daily intelligence briefs -- the President’s Daily Brief – delivered to each commander in chief from Kennedy to Ford. Among several metrics of lexical diversity, we focus our attention on the Measure of Textual Lexical Diversity (MTLD), which is commonly used in the fields of linguistics and education. Calculating these measures at both the overall brief and individual entry levels, we find evidence of a significant compression of lexical diversity over time, suggesting a convergence towards standardized terminology for intelligence reporting and analysis under the Nixon and Ford administrations. We also review archival qualitative evidence of the increasingly stringent writing protocols and guidelines issued by the Central Intelligence Agencies during the 1960s and 1970s. Applying insights from sociolinguistics and ethnographies of bureaucracy, we argue the collapse of discursive diversity is a result of intelligence agencies’ attempts to mimic technical expertise as a tactic for influence within government. Measuring and theorizing bureaucratization sheds light on when how bureaucracies acquire influence, why bureaucratic change is so difficult, and when bureaucratic dysfunctions are most likely to appear.

Authors