Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Can Encounters with the State Improve Minority-State Relations in Myanmar?

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Why and how do members of politically non-dominant ethnic groups develop attachment to the state? Using qualitative and quantitative data (election data, an original survey conducted in 2019 and a survey experiment to be conducted in spring 2021) from Myanmar, this paper examines the effect of ethnic minorities’ everyday encounters with the state (i.e., interpersonal interactions between citizens and agents of the state in local government offices) on their attachment to the state. It also tests whether everyday encounters with the state have an ameliorating effect in a conflict prone setting as well as the effect of power-sharing on improving minority-state relations.

Attachment to the state is defined in my research as an emotional bond an individual feels toward their country of citizenship. Existing explanations for minority-state relations focus on macro-level factors such as power-sharing, nation-building policies and public goods provision. In contrast, I propose a novel theory that highlights the role of interpersonal interactions. I argue that ordinary citizens’ attachment to the state is informed by their most tangible experiences of the state, which tend to occur in local government offices. Ordinary citizens in much of the developing world visit local government offices for routine matters. There at the office, citizens encounter street-level bureaucrats who provide privileged contacts with the state. Ethnic minorities who had positive encounters with the state develop stronger attachment to the state.

I conducted 17 focus-group interviews with ordinary ethnic minority citizens in 2018 to better understand the nature of the everyday encounters with the state in the Myanmar context. These interviews also revealed psychological impacts of the encounters.

Then in 2019, I led a team of local enumerators to implement an original survey in 35 townships with a substantial Chin and Kachin presence (822 households in 103 wards and villages). Chin and Kachin ethnic minority groups are selected from Myanmar’s numerous ethnic groups because Chin has a peaceful relationship with the state while Kachin has a long legacy of armed conflict that is on-going. I use a series of survey questions and a behavior indicator to gauge the respondents’ level of attachment to the state. The respondents were asked to rate their everyday encounters with the state. This survey data was then combined with the 2015 Myanmar election data to evaluate my hypothesis and the power-sharing hypothesis. I find that ethnic minorities who have had positive encounters with street-level agents of the state express stronger attachment to the state. I also find evidence of the ameliorating effect of everyday encounters with the state even when an ethnic group is in direct conflict with the state. Additionally, I find that power-sharing, specifically descriptive representation, does not have a consistent effect on ethnic minorities’ attachment to the state. I then evaluate generalizability of my findings beyond Myanmar by using data from the Asian Barometer Survey and the Latinobarometro.

I evaluate internal validity of my finding and the mechanisms linking the everyday encounters with the state and ethnic minorities’ attachment to the state using data from a survey experiment. The experiment consists of vignettes with two factors: positive/negative experience and direct/indirect experience of everyday encounters with the state.

Author