Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Trickle-Up Democracy: How Elite Philanthropy Entrenches Inequality in Myanmar

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Democracy is meant to encourage elected officials to improve the material lot of the ‘median voter’. Yet skeletal welfare regimes which do little for the poor endure in democratic contexts across the globe. This paper uses the case of Myanmar to examine how a low-taxing and precarious welfare regime has endured the end of direct dictatorship in 2011. Drawing on political ethnography of provincial patronage networks from Bago Region to national level between 2014 and 2018, especially Aung San Suu Kyi’s National League for Democracy, it argues that path-dependence of both material interests and ideals of ‘democracy’ enacted by activists, economic elites and some voters is undermining the redistributive possibilities of democracy. Focusing on the role of tycoons in funding social aid groups, public goods, disaster relief and political parties the paper argues that practices and ideals of non-state welfare provision entrenched during the autocratic austerity of the 1990s and 2000s have found their way into the heart of democratic practice since the transition to partial civilian rule. Grassroots activists and elected officials alike are now reticent either to resolve Myanmar’s land-grab crisis or to advance regulatory, taxation and social policy reforms critical to addressing dire inequality. Instead, self-professed democracy activists including elected parliamentarians hail non-state welfare provision, especially elite philanthropy, as consistent with the ideals of ‘democracy’ they championed during dictatorship and thus as morally superior to government-led social action. Drawing Myanmar into comparative literature on democracy and philanthropy, the paper concludes that the path-dependence both of interests and ideals of non-state welfare provision can entrench ‘trickle-up democracy’ by undermining capacity for and commitment to state social action and legitimising the affluence and influence of oligarchic elites.

Author