Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This study assesses the impact of politicization on aid effectiveness. Our understanding of aid effectiveness has improved substantially over the past two decades. Many conditioning factors have been explored and allow for better designing aid interventions. However, a number of gaps in our knowledge remain. To date, factors on the recipient side have received more attention than those on the donor side. Studies on donor-side factors have mostly focused on structural differences between donors, such as regime type and colonial history. We build on such work by examining political differences within the world’s largest donor country, the United States. Partisan polarization has been growing in the United States, and such divisions have affected foreign aid policy -- particularly in global health. The U.S. leads the world in global health financing and implementing global health programs. At the same time, political business cycles in the U.S. have generated major volatility in the amount and type of aid provided to reproductive health and related sectors. The past 20 years have seen the enactment, repeal, and subsequent reinstatement of the so-called “Global Gag Rule,” which restricts nongovernmental organizations in developing countries that receive USAID family planning funding from engaging in most abortion-related activities, even with their own funds. We demonstrate the material consequences of these fluctuations for outcomes including the prevalence of HIV/AIDS and rate of maternal mortality in recipient countries. Combining variation in partisan composition of Congress and Presidency and sectoral aid disbursement data from 1990-2018 with outcomes in all recipient countries, we demonstrate a substantial detrimental effect of U.S. aid on reducing the prevalence of HIV/AIDS. This effect is most pronounced where the U.S. is a dominant donor. Outcomes for which policy solutions are less likely to be politicized are not affected (e.g., child mortality). We argue that resistance of the United States to harmonize efforts with other members of the OECD Development Assistance Committee allows domestic polarization to affect outcomes in recipient countries. We supplement our quantitative analysis with case studies of projects in recipient countries facing implementation challenges as a consequence of such dynamics.