Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Soft power is an important element in a country’s foreign policy, which involves a country’s ability to obtain its foreign policy goals by attraction and co-optation rather than force and coercion (Nye 2004). A country with effective soft power could shape foreign audiences’ values and sway their opinion toward the communicating country through mobilizing national resources of culture, ideas, and technology (Nye 2008). Public diplomacy is an instrument of governments to communicate with audiences outside their national boundaries (Nye 2008). In the contemporary digital era, governments have realized the importance of social media platforms such as Twitter as channels through which diplomats can communicate with audiences abroad (Cha et al. 2010).
Even though Twitter has been banned in mainland China, Chinese diplomats have recently been active on Twitter, enabling a platform for practicing “wolf warrior” diplomacy. The label “wolf warrior diplomacy” has been used to describe China’s diplomatic style since 2017. In contrast to the older generation of Chinese leadership emphasizing cooperation and the maxim “bide its time and hide its strength,” the current Chinese leadership has seemed to adopt a more aggressive and combative approach.
Some well-known Chinese diplomats, such as Zhao Lijian and Hua Chunying, tend to combatively denounce criticism of China on Twitter. Zhao Lijian has been considered the “head wolf” of the “wolf warrior” diplomacy. He has gained prominence on Twitter because of his combative criticism toward Western countries, especially the United States. For example, in response to criticism of China’s Xinjiang reeducation camp, he criticized racial discrimination in the United States by tweeting, “In Washington, the white seldom go to SE area, as it’s an area for the black. President Trump even demanded 4 women lawmakers of color to leave US……Please follow “America First” & take care of racial discrimination.”
However, as a tool of public diplomacy, diplomats’ tweets are supposed to win agreement from the foreign public and promote its national images for soft power purposes. On the contrary, if those tweets only evoke aversion and irritation, the backfire could harm the country. Does aggressive messaging influence overseas public opinion in a positive way? This question remains unsettled and is the primary interest of the present study.
The secondary research interest lies in whether Twitter’s government labels have an effect of persuasion. Twitter has labeled all government accounts and state-affiliated media as “government account” and “state-affiliated media” since August in 2020. For example, Zhao Lijian’s Twitter account carries the label, “China government account.” Twitter government labels could convey warning messages to users and make them suspicious of the account’s information. How does the government label influence public diplomacy on Twitter? This is an important question that has been under-investigated. YouTube has adopted a similar policy for government accounts or state-backed media accounts. These labels certainly influence social media communication.
In this paper I plan to contribute to the study of social media-oriented soft power through a 2×2 survey experiment consisting of one control group and four treatment groups. Subjects in the control group will be asked to read two irrelevant tweets. Participants in each treatment group will read the two irrelevant tweets and two tweets from a Chinese diplomats’ Twitter account. Before completing the experiment, participants will be asked a series of baseline questions about demographics, ideology, partisanship, and international orientation. Respondents in the first treatment group will be exposed to two “positive-China” tweets with the “Chinese government account” label. Participants in the third treatment group will also be asked to read these two tweets, but the government labels will be hidden. Similarly, participants in the second treatment condition will read two “negative-United States” tweets with the Twitter government labels. Finally, subjects in the fourth treatment condition will be exposed to the same tweets without the government labels. All participants will then be asked a series of questions about their views on China, the United States–China relationship, democracy and U.S. institutions, and the United States’ and China’s handling of COVID-19.