Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Right of Resistance: from the Monarchomacs to Modern Republicanism

Sun, October 3, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

In the debate of contemporary political philosophy, the distinction between republicanism and liberalism has particular relevance. The rescue of republicanism by authors such as Quentin Skinner and Philip Pettit, among others, is based on a critique of the ideas of liberalism as regards the understanding of citizenship, the neutralization of politics through law, and the inability to actively challenge the state power. The articulating axis of the difference between these traditions would be the understanding of the concept of "freedom". Today, all republicans considere that Hobbes was the first in articulating a new conceptual framework to understand politics and power from an ideological innovation: freedom as non-interference; something that would have been crucial for the rise of liberalism.
Contemporary literature, whether republican or liberal, focuses on the legitimacy of the rule of law, its universality versus the possibilities for cultural exceptions to that rule of law, as well as the different ways in which government’s decisions might be challenged, coupled with the central debate on the conceptualization of "freedom as non-domination" versus "freedom as non-interference".
However, the analysis of citizenship’s phenomena as "a power to", in the same way Monarchomachs understood it, has been out of debate.
Our intention is to review the distinction between republican and liberal traditions on that particular point. In today's literature, a reconsideration of the influence of Monarchomachs ’ideas regarding the conceptual ideas of sovereignty and the right of resistance to arbitrary power is absent or overlooked when considering the elements that would distinguish republicanism from liberalism.
We will re-examine the extent to which the ideas of these Calvinist theorists (the Monarchomachs) regarding popular sovereignty, the social contract and the right to resist tyrannical power in particular, were key to the rise of modern republicanism in the Netherlands, especially in the works of Spinoza and the de la Court Brothers. This right to oppose to tyrannical power would be the foundation of modern republicanism, which would also make it more relevant in the face of phenomena such as authoritarianism.

Author