Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Problems with Tolerance

Sun, October 3, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Tolerance is considered a virtue in liberal tradition, and teaching tolerance is presented as a measure to prevent hate speech and hate crimes, if not discrimination in general. Although critics of liberalism have already addressed limitations of tolerance and the international human rights law introduced broader, more inclusive non-discrimination norms, tolerance is still invoked in human rights advocacy. It is valued at least as a middle-way policy between assimilation and extermination. Even the United Nations and its affiliated agencies promote teaching tolerance as a means of protecting human rights. However, there is an asymmetrical relationship between the ‘tolerant’ and the ‘tolerated,’ which must be questioned for its human rights implications. This paper contends that tolerance does not ensure nondiscrimination, freedom from persecution, or protection from hate speech and crimes; instead, it allows individuals to maintain their hatred and “othering,” and as a state policy, tolerance can be complicit in violence against marginalized groups. The paper proposes the promotion of recognition and respect as alternatives to tolerance and recommend comprehensive protective laws that do not tolerate hate speech and crimes as effective human rights policies.

Author