Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Reconciling Political-Moral Claims Beyond the Narrow Boundaries of the Public

Fri, October 1, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Democratic theorists have recently begun to reckon with the undemocratic implications of assuming the existence of a determinate people, to which any (theory of) democracy necessarily refers. Yet, debates over “the boundary problem” remain centered around questions of open vs. closed borders. This focus on justifying procedures for distinguishing insiders from outsiders and defining territorial units belies the nature of the problem. This paper puts forth a revision, which re-centers debate around the challenge of democratizing the processes by which individuals are transformed into political collectives that constitute the basis for democratic decision making and the justification of moral norms. Employing feminist critiques of the public-private divide, I demonstrate how narrow, static conceptions of political boundaries, like that of the nation, create constitutive exclusion, internally and externally, by examining two claims: First, that social inequalities created by national conceptions of membership, most often thought of as an external boundary, limit the ability of certain groups of citizens to fully develop the capacities required to meaningfully exercise their rights within the national state. And second, that this predicament is best understood through the lens of relational egalitarianism. Relational equality leads to the possibility that citizens can reduce these inequalities through procedures that enable their moral-political agency such that the political community can be continuously and democratically (re)defined. Further, I argue that scholars can develop a theory of such procedures by combining work on relational egalitarianism with discourse theories of democracy to better understand how to reconcile moral and political claims beyond the scope of the nationally bounded public sphere.

Author