Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Deliberative Democracy Explanatory Leverage in Ethnic Mobilization Studies

Sat, October 2, 2:00 to 2:30pm PDT (2:00 to 2:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

The paper explores deliberative capacity in the context of inter-cultural relations in post-Soviet Ukraine and Georgia. In particular, it focuses on (1) the effect of deliberative capacity on inter-cultural relations in these cases and (2) the factors that effect deliberative capacity itself.

The paper argues that deliberative capacity is the underlying feature of a multitude of ethnic mobilization theories. It suggests that instead of treating the different factors of ethnic tension as competing they can be looked at as complementary. I argue that the extent to which deliberative capacity is enabled by these factors is the root cause effecting ethnic identity mobilization. In other words, it is not just the separate factors that matter, but rather their effect on the deliberative capacity of the system. The suggested deliberative democratic perspective on interethnic relations simultaneously provides a more comprehensive and parsimonious story of ethnic mobilization.

This umbrella-argument was tested by the evidence from Ukraine and Georgia and was supported by it. The contingent constellation of political forces in Ukraine’s early transition contained crucial deliberative democratic elements of inclusion, moderation and reciprocity among the different ethno-cultural identity groups, which prevented the aggravation of social tension. In other words, the deliberative capacity of the system in the early years of Ukraine’s transition was comparatively high. In subsequent periods, however, new institutional and extra-institutional conditions - such as crucial events like the Orange Revolution, polarizing rhetoric and insensitive international discourses - decreased the level of deliberative capacity and thereby created a ground for the mobilization of ethno-cultural identities in Ukraine.

Furthermore, the paper argues that various factors affect different components of deliberative capacity in different ways and may create a trade-off between its dimensions. For example, the factor of Orange Revolutions had a mixed effect on deliberative capacity (affecting authenticity, consequentialism, and justification positively, while having a negative effect on moderation).

The paper also argues that different standings on different components of deliberative capacity create different types of deliberative capacity, which are consequential for democracy and public policy. Understanding the different kinds of deliberative systems and their different flaws is important for the ability to cure them with effective remedies.

On the level of political science, this work has responded to the lack of empirical research on deliberative systems. And on the level of ethnicity studies if offers a new way of looking at ethnic mobilization mechanism which is both parsimonious and providing explanatory leverage.

Author