Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Beyond Free Speech: The Educational Mission of the University

Tue, September 28, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Do universities have an obligation to shape students into more tolerant citizens capable of democratic deliberation across lines of deep disagreement? Our paper argues the affirmative and provides examples of policies that facilitate tolerance in a bottom-up rather than top-down manner.

It has become common in the campus free speech debates to refer to the mission of the university as epistemic (i.e. primarily concerned with the discovery and dissemination of knowledge). This idea is prominent both among those who argue that universities should maximally guarantee the protection of free speech on campus (Whittington 2018; Chemerinsky and Gilman 2017) and from those defending the university’s capacity to restrict speech in the name of academic standards (Simpson 2020).

We contend that the mission of the university goes beyond the epistemic. Specifically, we claim that the mission of the university includes shaping tolerant and open-minded students who can and are willing to engage with people who differ in their religious, moral, and political beliefs and who do so irrespective of differences in gender, race, class, or other ascriptive categories. Another way to put it is to say that shaping students’ character in a liberal direction is one of the goals of liberal education.

We argue that the rules governing speech on campus should be chosen with an eye to this broader mission of the university. This allows a broader range of speech-related university regimes than either an inflexible commitment to campus free speech (including hate speech) or strict commitments to restrictive speech codes. However, going beyond rules governing speech, we argue that universities should focus on encouraging and rewarding groups that exemplify the best approaches to deliberation across difference. This includes, among other policies, (1) establishing democratic procedures for nominating and selecting recipients of tolerance awards, and (2) focusing on output measures of toleration and effective deliberation rather than input measures related to speech regimes.

Authors