Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Empty Gift: Citizenship and American Imperialism in Puerto Rico

Fri, October 1, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

After nearly two decades under U.S. rule, the 1917 Jones Act granted American citizenship to Puerto Ricans. It is widely acknowledged, however, that this citizenship was and remains decidedly second-class. Why did Congress go to the trouble of granting a limited form of citizenship? This paper argues that the 1917 legislation was a response to lawmakers’ fears about political unrest on the island and to the international pressures of World War I. Lawmakers believed discontentment with American governance was growing, and internationally, World War I exacerbated U.S. desire to control the Caribbean and gain access to economic markets in Latin America. Withholding U.S. citizenship from Puerto Ricans undermined American diplomacy with Latin American countries and compromised America’s global reputation. This combination of bottom-up and top-down pressure on the U.S. government prompted Congress to pass legislation granting citizenship to Puerto Ricans. However, the citizenship was intentionally hollowed out so as not to unsettle existing racial hierarchy. Many of the rights and protections enjoyed by American citizens in the contiguous U.S. were not included in American citizenship for Puerto Ricans, and to this day remain unrealized. Granting second-class citizenship to Puerto Ricans was a legislative response to pressures on the U.S. government in the early 20th century that was compatible with white supremacy. At first glance, granting citizenship appears to be a progressive effort to affirm equality and rights. Upon further inspection, it becomes apparent that citizenship in this form enabled the American state to liberalize its imperial project. These insights have implications for our understanding of American imperialism and challenges conventional notions of citizenship.

Author