Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Computer Modeling, Climate Prophecy, and Public Faith in Science

Sun, October 3, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

This paper is part of a project about how climate science is transmitted and translated from knowledge infrastructures (robust networks of people, instruments, and institutions that generate and maintain knowledge of the human and natural worlds) into the public realm. In it, I identify and analyze three modes of public communication about climate science associated with three figures: the scientist, the technocrat, and the prophet. I focus on the newest of these rhetorics, which I call “climate prophesy.”

I begin by contrasting climate prophecy with the rhetoric of the climate scientist. Like Max Weber’s scientist, James Hansen’s testimony before Congress in 1988 confronted the public with inconvenient facts: global warming is real and anthropogenically caused. The climate prophet is also distinct from the climate technocrat, whose task is to calculate an acceptable level of global warming with reference to various parameters (the economic impact of rising seas on coastal cities, for example, or the highest wet bulb temperature the human organism can endure), and then to prescribe a carbon budget and determine its most economically efficient allocation.

Climate prophesy is enabled by the use of computer modeling for scenario projection, as seen, for example, in the representative concentration pathways (RCPs) described in the IPCC’s fifth assessment report. Unlike the famous hockey stick graph (which shows quantitative reconstructions of the mean global temperature for the past 500-2000 years based on climate proxy records), RCPs are always multiple and indeterminate. They are indeterminate not only because they factor in different socioeconomic choices and hypothetical future technologies, but also because they are embedded in a wider cosmology of unpredictable feedback loops and tipping points. A powerful visual rhetoric accompanies climate prophesy, in which spectacular images—collapsing ice-shelves, vast sinkholes opening in thawing permafrost, forlorn polar bears on vanishing ice floes—operate as natural signs and harbinger species of the coming apocalypse.

The temporal incongruities of climate modeling and scenario projection posit a politically salient gap between past and future, clearing a space for action and forcefully raising questions about responsibly, agency and their global distribution. Unlike the scientist or the technocrat, the climate prophet demands that we confront not just the facts of climate change, but the moral wrongs underlying it, like the voraciousness of capitalist consumption, histories of colonialism, and persistent global injustice. It presents democratic publics with their own complicity in these wrongs, and calls upon us to institute a radical turn in our lives and societies. Climate prophecy is more capacious than other modes of climate communication and aims to revitalize politics in more expansive ways. (As we’ve seen in attempts to link decarbonizing our industrial base with a jobs guarantee in the Green New Deal).

There is, of course, a vast literature (crossing history, sociology, and political theory) on the prophetic tradition in the US. In this paper, I am less interested in the social, cultural, political, and economic conditions that make prophesy particularly resonant in American public culture, than in the ways that computer modeling, in particular, enables new formulations of the prophetic voice. My aim is to contribute, from the perspective of political theory, to research in the social studies of science that examines the construction and contestation of facts. In particular, I am interested in how credibility within a scientific community is “build out,” as it were, into the public realm and made not just epistemically credible, but publicly authoritative. I argue that climate prophecy brings the technical and the moral together in new ways, that in doing so it calls into existence a public tasked with a monumental undertaking, and that its speculative facts and futures might even help found a renewed public faith in science and reason. Finally, I note that we can observe close parallels in the unfolding Covid-19 crisis: a public rhetoric we might call “pandemic prophesy” based on epidemiological forecasting and associated calls for political judgment and action.

Author