Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Mary Astell on Moderation: The Case of Occasional Conformity

Thu, September 30, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

In 1704, Mary Astell, known by many scholars as the “first English feminist,” published her pamphlet Moderation truly Stated. This was most immediately a polemical intervention in a heated partisan debate concerning the practice of occasional conformity –– the practice of conforming upon occasion to the sacraments of the Church of England in order to become eligible for public office under the Corporation Act 1661 and the Test Act, whilst still attending nonconformist religious meetings. The occasional conformity debate centred around the Occasional Conformity Bill, first proposed in 1702 by the Tories, which would prevent nonconformists or dissenters from the Church of England from holding public office by way of banning the practice of occasional conformity.

Astell’s Moderation truly Stated was written as a reply to James Owen’s pamphlet Moderation a Vertue (1703). In his pamphlet, Owen defended the practice of occasional conformity, and argued that occasional conformists were not hypocrites but men of moderation. For this reason, far from being harmful, the practice of occasional conformity could in fact be advantageous to the Church of England. The true threat to the Church, were not these men of moderation, but rather those “zealous Church men” (or women, like Astell herself) who opposed occasional conformity.

Astell avidly disagreed with Owen, and as I aim to show, argued persuasively that the men who practice occasional conformity must in fact by definition be hypocrites. Her self-proclaimed aim in writing Moderation truly Stated was to “endeavour as well as I can to settle the Point and to find out the true Meaning of Moderation,” (MTS, 3) as she sharply observed that the term moderation was invoked by all parties to suit their own agenda. She argued that the way Owen and other advocates of occasional conformity construed moderation certainly did not constitute a virtue.

Owen wrote a reply to his critics, Moderation still a Virtue (1704), but, to Astell’s dismay, did not acknowledge her pamphlet, nor respond to her arguments. Today, Astell’s Moderation truly Stated is still overlooked. It has been largely ignored by secondary literature: it was excluded from Patricia Springborg’s Cambridge edition of Astell’s Political Writings, and until today does not benefit from a modern edition. This is unfortunate, for it is in Moderation truly Stated that we find Astell’s original and persuasive critique of moderation as her contemporaries invoked it, as well as the formulation of her own conception of moderation.

Author