Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Across many advanced contexts, there has been a marked increase in households’ use of financial tools and services, illustrated by the growth of household debt and an increasing reliance on capitalized benefits. This trend emerged as many countries were facing fiscal stress in light of structural changes and increasing economic competition, which gave way to labor market and welfare state reforms. The concurrence of household financialization and welfare state reforms raises a number of key questions. First, what causes households to become increasingly reliant on the financial sector? Is this increasing dependence related to the economic pressures that led to welfare state reforms? Importantly, did politicians foresee that greater access to financial markets could substitute for the welfare state or was there another connection? If parties did view the expansion of financial tools and services as a partial solution to the fiscal burden of the welfare state, then why did some countries, despite facing similar fiscal policy challenges, forego expanding access? In order to answer these questions, I engage in systemic process tracing within a controlled comparison of the Netherlands and Germany (Hall 2006). The Netherlands and Germany are historically similar countries that have diverged significantly in regard to households’ reliance on the financial sector, despite facing parallel economic crises. Combing process tracing and a controlled case study facilitates the identification of key differences in the way that parties in these contexts approached welfare reforms in light of fiscal stress and understood the potential role of the financial sector. The implications of this work are important for rethinking how we conceptualize welfare regimes, specifically, in the age of financialization. My results may also potentially illuminate other contexts in which policymakers view the financial sector as a viable (partial or total) alternative to publicly provided social provision. This work contributes to the literature as there are few political accounts explaining the political causes of the trends in household financialization despite the opportune timing of the expansion of financial access and the essential role of policymaking in determining access to financial tools and services. In addition, the results provide insight into contexts that have shown resistance to expanding financial access to households, which have been paid relatively little attention in the literature on financialization.