Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Democracies Under Pressure: Online Incivility and Polarization in Italy

Thu, September 30, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Over recent years, especially since the U.S. Presidential Election and Brexit referendum in 2016, political communication has been surrounded by a debate concerning digital media-related threats to democracy: coordinated online hate campaigns, spread of disinformation, hostility and uncivil comments. This is a significant change considering that digital media were initially intended to be tools of liberation creating free and equal access to public discourse. The specific affordances of social media, combined with almost non-existent barriers to entry, have simplified for anyone to disseminate hostile content or carry out defamation and hate campaigns, thus contributing to polluting public debate, undermining social cohesion and democratic values.
Political incivility has become one of the most studied topics in this context, and the majority of the studies in this field show that it has increased in online communication from various actors (media system, representatives and candidates, ordinary users and others). However, it is difficult to confirm this trend since the concept has been operationalized in different ways and most approaches do not distinguish between the various types of incivility. A worrying result is that scholars have blended together rudeness and disrespectful communication forms with hate speech, violent threats and discrimination against minorities.
Starting from this perspective the paper analyses the online political discussion that surrounded the last General Election campaign in Italy (2018), which was characterised by a high level of polarization and political clashes between traditional parties and anti-establishment forces such as Lega and M5S. The latter in particular made extensive use of aggressive and uncivil communication, seeking to galvanise the electorate and channel its anger against the establishment parties. In this sense, it becomes important to investigate the discussion that took place throughout the election campaign among users interested in politics, in order to verify the level of incivility and hostility present and the polarization dynamics related to them.
In particular, by focusing on users who participated in the Facebook pages of political leaders, we aim at observing:
- how widespread are behaviours that threaten or violate democratic rules and values (hate speech, homophobia, racism, etc.) compared to forms of interpersonal incivility, such as profane language, gratuitous offence and intentional disrespect (name-calling, insults, personal attacks, mockery, etc);
- which factors are associated with the growth of the two types of incivility, by analysing the relationship between users’ comments and topics under discussion, as well as their relationship with the communication strategies adopted by political leaders in their posts (i.e. the use of uncivil versus civil language, divisive versus neutral topics).
We analysed a dataset of users’ comments (a sample of 125,436 comments) on posts (1,788) published on Facebook by the main candidates during the 2018 Italian General Election to identify the issues as well as the presence of hate-speech/antidemocratic comments vs interpersonal-incivility/impolite comments. A combination of manual and automated content analyses was performed and texts were classified through a supervised machine learning algorithm. Multiple linear regressions were used to verify the relationship between candidates’ posts and users’ comments.
The results show that the amount of democratically harmful comments, such as hate speech, is limited. This suggests that apocalyptic interpretations of how political discussions on social media pose a threat to democracy should be tempered. Moreover, the factors associated with hate speech and those related to interpersonal incivility in comments are different, so it makes sense to keep them distinct. In particular, hate speech is associated with right-wing communities and with users’ discussion regarding divisive issues, such as immigration, while interpersonal-incivility is likely to occur in bottom-up discussions, where issues disappear and users insult each other. Moreover, the online talk originating from politicians’ uncivil messages results in a deterioration of discussion quality with growing polarization and intolerance among users.
These results are important because they show that political incivility can contribute to an increase in polarization, but in ways that are no longer or only attributable to divisions concerning issues (e.g. affective polarisation has emerged). In this respect, the Italian case becomes an opportunity to reason about a phenomenon that is already internationally known and studied, i.e. political incivility, and its relation with polarization, but also a useful case study to determine whether the factors associated with the two forms of incivility are different, which would suggest a new research perspective for the future.

Authors