Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
More than 70,000 foreign-born immigrants acquired citizenship in 2018 and their share of the total eligible voter reached 10% in 2020. Reflecting this, experts have repeatedly described Asian Americans and Latinos as "Sleeping Giant" to emphasize their potential as the new voter. Contrary to this expectation, however, their levels of political participation such as voting, protest, political donation, etc, have never been higher, or even closer, to either White or Black. Especially, a large proportion of the new Americans, especially from racial minorities and immigrants, find no major political parties fit neatly to and represent their interest, ideologies, and identities and that the baseline partisanship for them is rather a non-identifier than either a partisan or an independent. Why the new Americans don't (join) join parties of the U.S.? What is the meaning of party attachment among early-generation Americans?
I try to extend our current knowledge of immigrant party identification by distinguishing a concept between "party identity as self-identification" and "meaning of party attachment". This question is important because existing studies in American politics have exclusively focused on "party identity as self-identification" rather than "meaning of party attachment". Here, the party identity as self-identification indicates a self-identification with a party where the meaning of party attachment indicates an expression of one's attachment to each party. This distinction is important for our understanding of how the new Americans develop their party identification because immigrants could develop their attachment to a political party while not internalizing the concept and meaning of political information, ideology, and identity. For example, one may identify with the Democratic (Republican) party because she ``is liberal (conservative)'' like native-born Americans while others may identify themselves as a Democrat because he/she thinks that ``the party is good for their country of origin''. Or, with reasons that particularly matter for them such as experiences/predispositions from their country of origin, "hate communism". In such cases, our understanding of immigrant partisanship will be limited if we only focus on self-identified partisanship, and that knowing about the meaning of party attachment, expressed by ordinary people, is crucial for our understanding of why the new Americans (don't) join the party in the U.S.
What is the meaning of their party attachment? Which early-generation Americans are more or less likely to develop and express their attachment to the political parties of the U.S. like native-born Americans? Building on studies on the consequences of polarization, I argue that increased clarity of party differences due to polarization has enabled immigrants to easily develop their attachment to major parties in the U.S. like native-born Americans. This is because the increased clarity reduces immigrants' ambivalence towards each political party and makes them easily understand the meaning and consequences of choosing one party over another. As a result, immigrants are required to have only the minimum level of ``what goes with what knowledge '' to develop their party attachment: individuals can develop and internalize their attachment towards political parties even without pre-adult socialization in the U.S. like native-born Americans once one can perceive differences in parties. In short, the increased clarity due to polarization complements the role that the pre-adult political socialization has played for Americans to the new Americans.
To document the impact of polarization on the development of party identification of these new Americans, I use the open-ended responses from American National Election Studies (ANES) that ask each respondent ``Is there anything in particular that you like
about the Democratic (Republican) Party? What is that? '' from 1984 to 2016, an item that the canonical work, The American Voter, used to understand American political concepts in the 1950s. However, it captures the degree to which immigrants have internalized the meaning of party attachment like native-born Americans as it is framed. To estimate this, I apply supervised machine learning techniques, SVM (Support Vector Machines). The strategy is to estimate the semantic similarity score for each first and second-generation immigrant using the SVM and trace the impact of polarization, via the increased clarity in party differences, on the development of the meaning of party attachment among immigrants.