Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Effects of Presidential Vulnerability on Ethnic Policy Innovation

Sun, October 3, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

The removal of Evo Morales from power in Bolivia in 2019 brought popular attention to extra-electoral transitions of power in presidential systems. On the heels of the widely known President’s departure from power, journalists debated what to call the event, with conceptual options ranging from “coup” to “popular democracy.” Indeed, such debates call to mind the scholarly debates and discussions of the past decades on the largely 21st century phenomenon of which Morales' departure was a case: failed or interrupted presidencies. Research since the turn of the 21st century has thus investigated such questions as the appropriate category under which such failed presidencies fall (Marsteintredet and Berntzen 2008), and even more so why such extra electoral turnovers have been such a steady and important part of Latin American politics in the 21st century (Edwards 2015; Hochstetler and Edwards 2009; Pérez-Liñán 2007; Valenzuela 2004). Thus, failed presidencies in the region have largely been discussed as an outcome in need of explanation, and for good reason – the phenomenon calls into question the strength and durability of electoral democracies (Negretto 2006; Pérez-Liñán 2005; Valenzuela 2004).

With third wave democracies now having seen these failed presidencies for a number of decades however, we can also begin to observe the effects stemming from the phenomenon. Indeed, while there is reason to be concerned about what such failed presidencies say about the state of electoral politics and democracy, particularly in new democracies where the system is arguably the most vulnerable, the original research I present in this paper also makes it clear that the widespread perception of vulnerability within the presidency has provided noteworthy incentives for policy innovation and growth, and sometimes, the inclusion of formerly marginalized actors.

In this paper, I argue that presidential vulnerability has incentivized presidents to innovate in the policy realm in order reach out to various groups that can play a role in keeping them in power. While the beneficiaries of presidential targeting are often powerful elite domestic groups and international actors, my research shows that such presidential vulnerability increases the likelihood of incorporating marginalized groups through policy as well, particularly when presidents perceive such groups as having the power to protest in their favor.

Empirically focusing on the cases of Ecuador and Peru, the paper examines the puzzle of right and center-right affiliated presidents that have enacted ethnic-inclusionary policy, such as bilingual education policy for indigenous communities, and policies that protect land rights of the indigenous people. As such policies fall outside of the right and center-right’s primary policy platforms, the question arises – why are such surprising actors reaching out to the indigenous communities with inclusionary policy? Examining the six center-right administrations in Ecuador and the four in Peru since democratization, I show that threats to presidential survival outside of the context of elections played a strong and significant role in right and center-right administrations reaching out to indigenous groups (and that indeed, in the absence of such threats, no such policy was made).

While Schattschneider and many that followed him suggested that threat and competition can lead to new actors being empowered, many have assumed that such competition and threat come only during election seasons. This research shows that threats to presidential power – outside of elections – are now playing a large role in policy decision making and the inclusion of marginalized actors, given the vulnerability of presidents’ hold on power even during their terms.

Thus, while it is of course crucial that we come to understand why presidencies are so vulnerable, it is also important that begin to understand what the outcomes of such vulnerability are. This study suggests that there may be some unforeseen consequences and benefits to unlikely actors.

Author